# I-638 Washington media codebook v3 (2026-11-16)

One codebook for every outlet. Every test was fixed before coding, and each one is paired with its mirror for the other side. Code what the story says, not what you expect. Every coded item needs an exact, verbatim quote of 40 words or fewer.

## The measure (ground truth)

- **Sec. 3(1):** school and WIAA rules must bar "biologically male students" from female-only individual or team competition. Boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected, so a trans girl can still play on them.
- **Sec. 3(2):** a girl entering female-only competition provides, "as part of the required routine sports physical examination", a form "signed by the student's personal health care provider that verifies the student's biological sex, relying only on one or more of": reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels. Any one of the three is enough. No exam or procedure is named, and school staff have no role.
- **Not in the text:** birth certificates as a basis, a testosterone threshold, or an age floor.
- **Before I-638:** WIAA rule 18.16.0 let students play in the category matching their gender identity, with **no hormone treatment required**. WIAA says it knows of "no more than approximately 10" trans athletes, and disclosure isn't required.
- **Status:** passed Nov 3, 2026 with about 56.8%; takes effect Dec 3, 2026; sued Nov 9-10, 2026. Sponsor: Let's Go Washington, funded mostly by Brian Heywood. Large No donors include Inatai Foundation ($1M), SEIU 775 ($750K) and ACLU of Washington ($332K).

## Corpus and units

- **Window:** 2025-06-01 to 2026-11-16. Include every item about I-638, or about trans athletes in Washington school sports.
- **Item types:** `news` (news, explainer, fact check, broadcast transcript), `opinion` (editorial, column, op-ed, letter), `wire` (AP or another outlet's story, run unchanged).
- **Origin:** `staff`, `syndicated:<source>` (e.g. syndicated:WA State Standard), or `wire:AP`. Bias measures count only `news` with origin `staff`. Opinion and wire are kept and reported separately.
- **McClatchy papers** (News Tribune, Olympian, Tri-City Herald, Bellingham Herald) share stories. Code each unique story once under the outlet that wrote it, and list the others in `also_ran_in`.
- **Paywalls:** fetch only what loads without logging in. Code a story from its full text if it loads in full. If only part loads, set `read_status=partial` and code just what you can read. Never bypass a paywall.
- **Minors:** never name one. Write "a trans athlete", "a Camas runner", "a girl".

## Output 1: stories.csv (one row per story)

`story_id,outlet,date,author,headline,url,type,origin,also_ran_in,read_status,words,`
`src_yes_personal,src_yes_expert,src_yes_official,src_yes_campaign,src_no_personal,src_no_expert,src_no_official,src_no_campaign,src_neutral,`
`first_word,last_word,`
`harm_headline,harm_lead,harm_lead_quote,harm_paras_trans,harm_paras_girls,`
`p_fund_trig,p_fund_pass,p_lab_trig,p_lab_pass,p_tie_trig,p_tie_pass,p_gap_trig,p_gap_pass,p_doc_trig,p_doc_pass,p_scope_trig,p_scope_pass,p_few_trig,p_few_pass,p_hrt_trig,p_hrt_pass,p_poll_trig,p_poll_pass,`
`opinion_side,notes`

### Sources: count each person quoted or paraphrased, once per story

Each source gets a side (Yes, No or neutral) and a role:
- **personal:** a student, parent or coach speaking from experience.
- **expert:** a doctor, scientist or lawyer explaining the substance.
- **official:** an elected official, agency or WIAA.
- **campaign:** a campaign spokesperson or consultant.

A person's side comes from what they say or whom they work for. A doctor who signed the No statement counts as No even if the story doesn't say so.

### First and last word

Which side's source is quoted first, and which last: `yes` / `no` / `none`.

### Harm (test H)

- `harm_headline`, `harm_lead` (first 3 paragraphs): `trans` / `girls` / `both` / `neither`.
- Harm is a negative effect the story describes. **To trans students:** exclusion, harassment, being singled out, mental-health effects, loss of rights. **To girls:** lost places or roster spots; unfair or unsafe competition; locker-room privacy; being punished, harassed or silenced for objecting; exams or paperwork for all girls.
- A headline that only says what the measure does ("ban on trans girls in girls sports") isn't harm by itself. It takes explicit harm words, or a named harmed person.
- `harm_paras_*`: count of paragraphs describing each group's harm.

### Paired omission tests

`*_trig` is Y/N; `*_pass` is Y / N / partial. Code a pass only when the trigger fires. Put the trigger and pass quotes in `notes`, or as rows in items.csv under the type `omission`.

| Test | Trigger: the story… | Pass: it also… | Mirror |
|---|---|---|---|
| p_fund | names Heywood or Let's Go Washington funding | names a No-side donor or the No side's funding | the same test, read in reverse: when No funding is named, is Yes funding named? (note it) |
| p_lab | labels the Yes side politically ("conservative", "GOP-backed", "Republican-allied") | labels the No coalition at all ("progressive", "union-backed", "Democratic-allied") | the reverse |
| p_tie | quotes an expert who has a campaign tie | discloses that tie | same for either side |
| p_gap | prints a Yes fairness or advantage concern | gives any number for the male performance gap | — |
| p_few | prints a Yes fairness or advantage concern | gives the small number of trans athletes (WIAA's ~10, or "few") | mirror of p_gap |
| p_hrt | discusses whether trans girls have an advantage, or whether competition is fair | says WA required no hormone treatment, or that trans girls in WA may have gone through male puberty (record voice: own/quote) | mirror of p_few |
| p_doc | prints that I-638 requires or could require genital or pelvic exams | says the check is by the girl's own provider, or that genetics or testosterone are alternatives | the Yes claim "physicals already record sex" → says they don't |
| p_scope | describes what the measure does | says or makes clear that trans girls can still play on boys' or open teams, or that it covers girls' teams only | — |
| p_poll | cites a poll | gives the pollster, its lean or ties, or the date / margin of error | same for either side's polls |

## Output 2: items.csv (one row per statement)

`story_id,outlet,date,para,quote,voice,item_type,claim_code,favors,whats_true,correction,notes`

- **voice:** `own` (the outlet's own words, including headline, deck, captions and narration), `paraphrase` (attributed and unquoted), or `quote`.
- **item_type:**
  - `false`: a firm factual error, contradicted by the text or primary data.
  - `misleading`: an arguable error, or a claim missing context that changes its meaning.
  - `framing`: one side's characterization presented as the outlet's own.
  - `hedged_check`: the outlet rebuts a claim, but leaves it partly standing ("does not *explicitly* require").
  - `flat_check`: the outlet rebuts a claim plainly.
  - `unchecked`: a side's claim printed with no context anywhere in the story.
  - `omission`: a paired-test trigger and its result.
  - `accurate`: a correct statement of a contested point. Record these too; they show where outlets got it right.
- **claim_code:** use these codes.
  - **No side:** NGEN (requires genital exams), NEXT (most extreme), N510 (5-10 athletes), N147 (girls without a doctor), NDISC (discourages girls), NCLOTHED, NMEGA (megadonor), NBC (birth certificates), NAGE8, NNOEDGE (no athletic advantage / research inconclusive), NNOVERIFY (sex can't be reliably verified).
  - **Yes side:** YDOC (physicals already record sex), YAAP, YBIRTH (birth records suffice), Y269, YBAN (bans no one), YFED (federal/IOC).
  - **Either side:** SCOPE (says it bars trans girls from sports in general, not just girls' teams), OTHER (describe it).
- **favors:** which side the statement helps, if it's wrong or one-sided: `yes` / `no` / `neutral`.
- **whats_true:** one sentence, citing the measure's text or a primary source.
- **correction:** `corrected` / `not corrected` / `unknown`. Look for correction or editor's notes on the page.

## Opinion

For each opinion item, record `opinion_side` (`yes` / `no` / `mixed`) and its author. Don't code departures in opinion pieces; they're opinions. One exception: an unsigned editorial is the outlet's own voice, so code its factual errors in items.csv with voice `own` and a note saying "editorial".

## Quality

- Every quote must match the source file exactly; a script will check this.
- When unsure, pick the more conservative code and say why in `notes`.
- Code both directions with equal care. An outlet with no departures is a real result.

## Placement for the claim grid (added 2026-11-17)

Each coded statement about one of six questions voters heard is placed in one of five columns:
Wrong (helped Yes), Slanted (helped Yes), Right, Slanted (helped No), Wrong (helped No).

- **In the paper's own words:** `false` goes to Wrong; `misleading`, `framing` and `hedged_check` go to Slanted; `accurate` and `flat_check` go to Right. The side is the item's `favors`.
- **A side's claim printed with no check (`unchecked`):** placed by FactHub's rating of that claim. False goes to Wrong, Misleading to Slanted, Mostly true to Right. Rows: genital exams (False, wa-i638-genital-exam-claim), no athletic edge (False, trans-girls-athletic-advantage), bans trans girls from sports (Misleading, wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports; the measure covers girls' teams only), most extreme (Misleading, wa-i638-most-extreme), sex can't be verified (False, wa-i638-verification-accuracy), a doctor's checkbox (Mostly true, wa-i638-yes-campaign-claims). Other claims are placed as Slanted toward the side they help, with three exceptions set by hand: the "80 to 90%" poll claim (Wrong; I-638 passed with about 56.8%), the hernia-check claim (Slanted), and the 5-10 athlete estimate (Right).
- **Errors that help neither side** (typos, a wrong detail about another state's law) are not placed.
- **Omission rows** (`item_type` omission) are the quotes that set off a paired test. They are statements, not placements.

## Story rows in the claim grid (added 2026-11-18)

The question "Did Washington require trans girls to take hormones to compete?" is answered at the story level, not the statement level. Each story whose `p_hrt_trig` is Y (it discussed whether trans girls have an advantage or whether competition is fair) is one dot: Slanted (helped No) when `p_hrt_pass` is N, Right when it is Y or partial. Each such story has one statement (`claim_code` HRT, `item_type` omission) quoting a sentence that shows it raised fairness, so readers can check why it was included. Claim-grid rows carry `unit` = statement or story; counts of statements and stories are never added together.

The mirror test, whether a story that raised fairness gave the small number of trans athletes (`p_few`), is kept in the stories table and the omission-tests analysis (24 of 49 did). It is not a row in the claim grid, because what that number means for fairness is disputed and the count changes from year to year.
