Audits
Is bird flu driving up turkey prices this Thanksgiving?
Version 2. FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. What this means · All auditors
Across versions
| Version | First Look |
|---|---|
| Version 2 | 7/7 |
| Version 1 | 7/7 |
First Look
A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.
- Title matches the evidence
- No obvious contradictions
- Plausible justification
- Sources are relevant
- Common questions answered
- Headline and verdict agree
- No Wikipedia or open wikis
7 checks
-
Pass Title matches the evidence
The title asks whether bird flu is driving up turkey prices this Thanksgiving. The evidence shows turkey prices up (wholesale about doubled in 2025, shopper and store-index prices up about 10% in 2026), while this fall's outbreaks are about half of last fall's. The Mixed rating says partly, which fits that mix. No number or scope in the title goes beyond the evidence.
-
Pass No obvious contradictions
The Mixed finding matches the answer ('does cost more, partly from past bird flu losses, but this fall's outbreaks are half of last fall's') and the conclusion's 'half right'. Spot-checked figures agree across sections: 96 cents against 182 cents wholesale is about 53%, 1.08 million against 2.10 million is about half, late-2025 against late-2024 wholesale is about 84% higher, and the 2027 forecast of 145 cents is about 18% below 177 cents. The conclusion's statement that bird flu 'did push turkey prices up' is qualified later in the same text as one factor among several, which is nuance rather than contradiction.
-
Pass Plausible justification
The conclusion explains the rating: the claim holds as one reason among several (higher store prices, a flock still rebuilding from disease losses), but not as this fall's outbreaks pushing prices up, since outbreaks are smaller, supplies are growing, and a second virus, costs and demand also matter. That reasoning follows from the evidence shown and supports a Mixed rating.
-
Pass Sources are relevant
The sources are USDA reports and datasets on wholesale, retail, production, outbreaks and cold storage; Farm Bureau market and survey reports; and an NBC News 2025 turkey price story. Each is on topic for the turkey-price and bird-flu claims it supports. The FactHub records for the WJLA and analyst statements are on topic for tracing the claim.
-
Pass Common questions answered
There are nine common questions, each with a response that addresses it: store sale prices versus wholesale, share of turkeys hit by bird flu, 2024 versus 2025 outbreaks, the 8 to 10 percent price rise, what else keeps prices high, whether 2025 was a rebound, last Thanksgiving, whether supply is a delayed effect, and whether prices will fall next year.
-
Pass Headline and verdict agree
Step b sentence: 'Is bird flu driving up turkey prices this Thanksgiving? Yes and no.' That tells readers bird flu is partly driving prices up, which matches the claim (bird flu is driving up prices this Thanksgiving), the Mixed finding, and the answer that it is partly from past losses but this fall's outbreaks are half of last fall's. Both the title and the claim are positive questions, so there is no polarity problem.
-
Pass No Wikipedia or open wikis
Every cited source is a FactHub dataset record, a Farm Bureau publication, a USDA agency report or dataset (WASDE, ERS, AMS, NASS), or an NBC News article. Their URLs are on fb.org, usda.gov, ams.usda.gov, and nbcnews.com. The institutions named in evidence (USDA, Farm Bureau, BLS, NBC, WJLA) are not open wikis. The only Wikimedia link is the credited barn photo's source, which the rules exempt.
Coverage: I audited the article JSON only. I did not open source snapshots or the web. The source takeaways in the sources block are all marked 'not yet checked', so I treated them as unchecked: I did not rely on them to confirm any fact, and I judged the article's claims only on their internal consistency and on whether the cited sources are on topic. The article's key points are marked established, and I took them at their word for what they state, not for source accuracy. I checked internal consistency across the title, claim, finding, answer, conclusion, key points, evidence summaries, objections, charts and changelog. I checked the arithmetic behind the main figures: 96 against 182 cents is about 53 percent, 1.08 million against 2.10 million is about half, late-2025 against late-2024 wholesale is about 84 percent higher, and the 2027 forecast of 145 cents is about 18 percent below 177 cents. I checked the title against the claim, finding and answer for polarity. I checked every cited source's name, title, description, URL and reliability note, plus the institutions named in evidence, for open-wiki status. The only wiki link is the credited photo's source, which passes. No external specialist review is recorded, and I did not assess that.