Audits
Did Abraham Lincoln make Thanksgiving a yearly national holiday?
Version 1. FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. What this means · All auditors
Across versions
| Version | First Look |
|---|---|
| Version 1 | 7/7 |
First Look
A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.
- Title matches the evidence
- No obvious contradictions
- Plausible justification
- Sources are relevant
- Common questions answered
- Headline and verdict agree
- No Wikipedia or open wikis
7 checks
-
Pass Title matches the evidence
The title asks whether Lincoln made Thanksgiving a yearly national holiday. The evidence shows an unbroken run of national proclamations from 1863 through 1945 (ev-yearly), and the article's caveats on date-setting and the 1941 law are stated. The scope matches the evidence.
-
Pass No obvious contradictions
The Mostly true finding matches the conclusion's rating. Key point 1 (83 years in a row, 1863-1945) and key point 2 (4 of 74 years, 1789-1862, none 1816-1861) match the summary and ev-gap. Key point 4 (each president chose the date until 1941) matches the conclusion and ev-yearly. Caveats such as the 1862 call and the 1939 state count are nuance, not contradictions.
-
Pass Plausible justification
The conclusion explains that Lincoln's proclamation covered one year and bound no one, that each later president picked the date, and that Congress fixed the fourth Thursday in 1941. That reason plausibly supports Mostly true rather than True.
-
Pass Sources are relevant
Every cited source is on topic by name and description: presidential proclamations, the Continental Congress journals, Hale's letter and Godey's editorials, the Welles diary, the Prologue and Archives histories, the 1870 and 1941 statutes, the U.S. Code, Jefferson's letter, Winslow's account, and the FactHub dataset records.
-
Pass Common questions answered
The article has nine common questions, and each response addresses its question. The obj-confed response is candid that Confederate observance was not checked, which is an honest limit rather than a dodge.
-
Pass Headline and verdict agree
Step b sentence: 'Did Abraham Lincoln make Thanksgiving a yearly national holiday? Mostly yes.' Step c: readers take away that Lincoln mostly did make it a yearly national holiday. The claim is positive with no negation, the finding is Mostly true, and the answer agrees, so a Yes to the title means the claim is true.
-
Pass No Wikipedia or open wikis
No cited source is Wikipedia or another open wiki. Publishers and institutions are the American Presidency Project, Library of Congress, National Archives, Government Publishing Office, Cornell, University of Vermont, Houghton Mifflin, and FactHub. The Wikimedia Commons credit for the photo is not a cited source.
Coverage: I read the article text in the payload only: title, claim, finding, answer, conclusion, context, description, evidence items with their summaries and limitations, objections with responses, key points, method, editorial note, and the source list with names, descriptions, reliability notes and takeaway statements and quotes. I did not open any source, snapshot or URL, as instructed. Every takeaway in the input carries status 'not yet checked', so none is marked established. I therefore treat all source-level takeaway claims as unchecked and did not verify that any quote supports its statement. The key points carry the article's own 'established' labels; I checked them only for consistency with the conclusion and evidence text, not against the takeaways. The FactHub dataset records (src-ds-period, src-ds-years, src-ds-off, src-ds-split) were read only as their titles, descriptions and takeaway statements; I did not inspect the underlying tables. The 1939 state count rests on a 1990 Prologue transcription, which the article itself flags as contested, and I did not try to resolve that. Check 6 was worked through as required: the title is a question, the finding Mostly true gives Mostly yes, and the claim is positive, so the reader takeaway agrees. Check 7 covered every source name, publisher, institution and URL, plus the image credit, and found no open wiki.