Audits
Is Thanksgiving dinner more expensive than it used to be?
Version 3. FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. What this means · All auditors
Across versions
| Version | First Look |
|---|---|
| Version 3 | 7/7 |
| Version 1 | 7/7 |
First Look
A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.
- Title matches the evidence
- No obvious contradictions
- Plausible justification
- Sources are relevant
- Common questions answered
- Headline and verdict agree
- No Wikipedia or open wikis
7 checks
-
Pass Title matches the evidence
The title asks whether Thanksgiving dinner is more expensive than it used to be. The evidence shows a dollar rise (about twice 1986) alongside a real-terms decline (2025 and 2026 are the two cheapest years after inflation), so the title neither overstates nor reverses the evidence.
-
Pass No obvious contradictions
Finding Misleading matches the answer's split between dollars (up 6%) and inflation-adjusted results (second cheapest). The conclusion, key points, evidence summaries and objection responses use the same figures: 56.30 vs 84.38 is 33% lower, 56.30 vs 69.73 is 19% lower, the 2020 gap is under 4%, and the grocery check agrees. No section states an incompatible number or treats a disputed item as settled.
-
Pass Plausible justification
The conclusion separates the dollar measure, which holds, from the affordability reading, which does not, and explains why the result is Misleading rather than False: the dollar facts are accurate and the 2026 bill is slightly above 2025 even after inflation. The reason follows from the cited evidence.
-
Pass Sources are relevant
Farm Bureau releases, datasets and economist analyses cover the survey; Walmart, Century Foundation and Groundwork, the White House, Agriculture Secretary Rollins's op-ed and PolitiFact each cover the price claim they are cited for. None is off-topic for the claims it supports.
-
Pass Common questions answered
There are ten objections, and each response addresses its question: work time, this year versus last, record, Walmart 25%, Rollins's comparison, 10% a year, turkey, bigger menu, grocery adjustment and farm-lobby trust.
-
Pass Headline and verdict agree
Step b sentence: 'Is Thanksgiving dinner more expensive than it used to be? Not the way it sounds.' Step c: the reader takes away that dinner is not pricier in the way the question implies. Step d: this matches the claim 'Thanksgiving dinner is more expensive than it used to be' (same positive polarity and scope), the Misleading finding, and the answer's split between dollars and after-inflation results.
-
Pass No Wikipedia or open wikis
Cited sources are the American Farm Bureau Federation, FactHub records, Walmart, The Century Foundation and Groundwork Collaborative, The White House, Fox News and PolitiFact. Institutions named in evidence (BLS, USDA) are not open wikis. The Wikimedia Commons image credit is not a cited source and is allowed.
Coverage: Read only the article payload, the element list and the source takeaways supplied here. I did not read source snapshots or the web, and I did not verify any figure against a source. Every takeaway in the sources block is marked status 'not yet checked', so no takeaway is marked established. My checks therefore cover internal consistency, relevance, polarity and the open-wiki lookup only; the figures are unverified. I re-derived some arithmetic from the article text: 58.63 over 28.74 is about 2.04 times; 56.30 over 84.38 is 33% lower; 56.30 over 69.73 is 19% lower; 56.30 over 58.42 is about 3.6% lower; 56.30 over 68.84 is about 18% lower; 107 over 191 is about 56%; 58.63 over 55.18 is 6.3%. The stated 3.4% work-time rise for 104 to 107 minutes is 2.9% on the rounded minutes, which could be rounding in the unrounded values, so I did not flag it. Two observations for the source checkers rather than findings here: the key points are labelled established while the takeaways behind them are not yet checked, and the article cites BLS as a method source without a separate BLS source entry. The bigger-menu response says early years used bone-in ham; no takeaway supports that, and I could not see whether it is accurate. I did not judge the editorial standards, the disclosure, or whether the Farm Bureau survey is a reliable measure.