← Back to the article

Audits

Is Thanksgiving the peak day for home cooking fires?

Version 1. FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. What this means · All auditors

Across versions

Version First Look
Version 1 7/7

First Look

0 material, 0 minor, 7 of 7 passed · version 8 · claude-haiku-5-5 · 17 November 2026

A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.

7 checks
  1. Pass Title matches the evidence

    The title asks whether Thanksgiving is the peak day for home cooking fires, and the evidence (federal records topping every year 2020-2025, plus NFPA estimates) supports that direction and scope.

  2. Pass No obvious contradictions

    The finding True matches the answer, conclusion and High confidence. The 3.1 to 4.2 range, 741 vs 219 in 2024, and 1.9/1.8 holiday multiples match across key points, evidence and objections. The 2025 'more than twice' claim (780 vs 359) holds, and the limitation and key points agree on the 2025 caveat.

  3. Pass Plausible justification

    The conclusion gives a clear reason for True: the same ranking appears in six years of federal counts and in NFPA and federal agency estimates built on those records, and the stated limits do not change the order.

  4. Pass Sources are relevant

    Every cited source (FactHub NFIRS dataset, USFA NFIRS and snapshot pages, NFPA Thanksgiving, cooking and home cooking fire pages, CPSC Thanksgiving and fryer releases, and a YubaNet reprint of an NFPA release) is on topic for the holiday cooking fire claim it supports.

  5. Pass Common questions answered

    There are eight common questions, and each response addresses its question directly, including fryers, Christmas, Super Bowl, undercounting, the 3 to 4 times figure, deaths, conflicting numbers and what to do with a pan fire.

  6. Pass Headline and verdict agree

    Title 'Is Thanksgiving the peak day for home cooking fires?' with short answer 'Yes' (finding True) reads 'Is Thanksgiving the peak day for home cooking fires? Yes.', which tells readers Thanksgiving is the peak day, matching the claim and answer; the claim has no negation.

  7. Pass No Wikipedia or open wikis

    All cited sources are FactHub, U.S. Fire Administration, NFPA, CPSC or YubaNet, and the named institutions are FEMA, NFPA and CPSC. No Wikipedia or other open wiki appears as a source.

Coverage: Read the full article payload: title, claim, finding, answer, confidence, summary, key points, conclusion, context, method, evidence items with limitations, objections with responses, sources with takeaways, reliability notes and URLs, and the institutions named in evidence. I did not read any source pages, snapshots or the web. Every takeaway in the sources block is marked 'not yet checked', and none is marked established, so I did not rely on any takeaway as verified. The three key points marked established are the article's own key points, not takeaways. My checks rest on internal consistency of the article text and on the source metadata. Points I could not verify and did not treat as findings: the NFPA 'no civilian deaths 2020 through 2024' takeaway and its quoted 'these years'; the USFA snapshot quote 'These fires caused an estimated annual average of 5 deaths', which the article reads as all home fires from every cause, though the quote's referent is not visible here; the NFPA 388 percent wording for 2023 against 321 percent for 2024, which the article already flags; and the NFPA 1,470 'a year' phrasing, which the source describes as per average Thanksgiving. Source accuracy, quote fidelity and the fairness of each takeaway are for the Source Checker and Skeptic. I also noted that the day before Thanksgiving was the 2025 runner-up (359), while the conclusion names Christmas as runner-up, but that comparison uses different averaging periods, so I did not count it as a contradiction.