Audits
Does I-638 ban transgender girls from school sports?
Version 1. FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. What this means · All auditors
Across versions
| Version | First Look |
|---|---|
| Version 1 | 7/7 |
First Look
A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.
- Title matches the evidence
- No obvious contradictions
- Plausible justification
- Sources are relevant
- Common questions answered
- Headline and verdict agree
- No Wikipedia or open wikis
7 checks
-
Pass Title matches the evidence
The title 'Does I-638 ban transgender girls from school sports?' is the claim being tested, not a finding. The evidence (e-text, e-girls-only, e-wiaa) shows the bar covers girls' competition only, and the Misleading rating and conclusion say the same, so the title does not claim a scope the evidence lacks.
-
Pass No obvious contradictions
The finding Misleading matches the answer ('bars transgender girls from girls' teams ... but leaves boys' and mixed teams open') and the conclusion ('the claim is wrong in its scope ... Misleading'). Key points 1 to 4 agree with the conclusion, and the caveats about rewritten WIAA rules are nuance rather than contradiction.
-
Pass Plausible justification
The conclusion gives a readable reason for Misleading: the text and WIAA rules leave boys' and mixed teams open, while the claim is accurate only read as a girls'-sports ban. It also names the practical limits and why confidence is High.
-
Pass Sources are relevant
Each source fits its use by name and description: the filed text, the Attorney General's explanatory statement, WIAA handbooks, news reports on WIAA and OSPI statements, the Seattle Times stories for headlines and the WIAA estimate, the lawsuit complaint, and FactHub campaign-statement records.
-
Pass Common questions answered
There are eight common questions, each with a response that addresses it, including whether boys' teams are an option, whether the WIAA can exclude, whether boys are barred, and whether headlines reported a ban.
-
Pass Headline and verdict agree
Step a: Misleading gives 'Not the way it sounds'. Step b: 'Does I-638 ban transgender girls from school sports? Not the way it sounds.' Step c: the reader learns the measure does not ban them from school sports the way it sounds. Step d: the claim is a positive statement ('I-638 bans transgender girls from school sports'), with no negation, and the finding and answer agree that the wording is misleading, so the sentence agrees.
-
Pass No Wikipedia or open wikis
No cited source is Wikipedia or another open wiki. The sources are the Washington Secretary of State, the WIAA, Spokesman-Review, The Center Square, Seattle Times, the plaintiffs' complaint and FactHub records. The institutions named in evidence items, including OSPI and the Attorney General's Office, are not wikis either.
Coverage: I read the article payload, including evidence items, limitations, key points, objections, conclusion, method, and the source takeaway statements and quotes. I did not open the source documents or the web, per instructions. Every source-level takeaway carries status 'not yet checked', so I did not treat any of them as established. Key points are labelled established, but the source takeaways beneath them are unchecked, so my reading of key points is limited to internal consistency with the conclusion and the other sections. I could not verify the filed text, the Attorney General's pamphlet statement, the WIAA handbook, the news quotes, or the complaint. For check 7 I looked at the name, publisher, title, description and URL of every source, and at the institutions named in evidence items; none is an open wiki. The image credit to FactHub Research Team is not a cited source. For check 6 I worked through the title question step by step, as required.