Audits
Washington's spending growth beyond inflation is 5-9 times the millionaires tax's 2027-29 revenue
Version 2 (draft). FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. All auditors
Across versions
First Look
A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.
- No obvious contradictions
- Title matches the evidence
- Plausible justification
- Sources are relevant
- Common questions answered
5 checks · 1 concern
-
Concern (minor) No obvious contradictions
Dataset sources are named v3 but the changelog and nodeHandles cite version 4; rename the sources to v4.
Every dataset source is named 'FactHub dataset: Washington general fund growth, v3', but the changelog says 'cites dataset version 4' and each dataset nodeHandle ends in ':4'. The finding, answer and conclusion otherwise agree, and the share-of-income and outlook figures reconcile within rounding. Fix: rename the seven dataset source titles to v4.
About source:ds-excess, source:ds-gap, source:ds-base, source:ds-share, source:ds-area, source:ds-groups, source:ds-exk12 The finding
-
Pass Title matches the evidence
Title's 5-9 times ratio matches the $16.9-21.2B excess against $2.31-3.50B of 2027-29 tax revenue (about 4.8-9.2 times), and the direction matches the evidence.
-
Pass Plausible justification
The conclusion explains True from the consistent path comparison across three price measures, the 0.11-0.21 ratio of tax to excess, and the caveats on base year and tax growth.
-
Pass Sources are relevant
Sources are the dataset analyses, fiscal note, legislative budget notes, Attorney General statement, Research Council pieces and State Auditor reports, each matching the tax revenue, outlook, relief, spending composition or audited waste it supports.
-
Pass Common questions answered
Seven objections each receive a response that addresses the question, including the full-year, share-of-economy, court-order, waste and Medicaid questions.
Coverage: Read only the article JSON, its elements list and the source takeaway text. Did not open sources, snapshots, chart images or related articles. Every source takeaway is marked 'not yet checked', so none was treated as established and no check relies on a source quote being accurate. Cross-checked arithmetic: 5-9 times ratio, one-ninth to one-fifth shares, outlook shortfalls (0.65 less 2.70 and 3.50, and -0.924 less 3.50), K-12 at 38% of the excess, and share-of-income benchmarks, all reconciling within rounding. Did not judge whether sources support the stated figures.