The short version
Claim we investigated
The Pilgrims ate turkey at the first Thanksgiving in 1621.
Mostly true. Probably: wild turkeys were plentiful and hunted that fall, though the only eyewitness account names just deer and fowl. Turkey was probably served, but no record says so. The one eyewitness letter names only deer and "fowl," while the governor's later history says the colonists took "many" wild turkeys that fall.
Quote or cite this fact-check
FactHub rates the claim “The Pilgrims ate turkey at the first Thanksgiving in 1621” Mostly true (moderate confidence): Probably: wild turkeys were plentiful and hunted that fall, though the only eyewitness account names just deer and fowl. Reviewed November 16, 2026. https://facthub.org/n/article/pilgrims-turkey-first-thanksgiving/1
Key points
What the evidence establishes
- Established. The only eyewitness account names two foods: five deer brought by Wampanoag hunters and a week's worth of wildfowl.
- Established. Governor Bradford wrote that besides waterfowl there was "great store of wild turkeys, of which they took many" that fall.
- Established. Writers of the time counted turkeys as "fowl," so the birds the four hunters brought back could have included turkeys.
- Established. Plimoth Patuxet museum historians call turkey "very likely," reasoning from Bradford's line and what "fowl" meant then. One thinks duck or goose was the main bird.
- Not shown. No 1621 account says turkey was the centerpiece. Turkey took that role in the 1800s.
- Context. Mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie were not on the 1621 table.
The evidence
The conclusion rests on the combined record. Expand each item to see its role and limitations.
| Method | Institution / country | Year(s) | What it shows | Key limitation | Primary links |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reading of the primary text: Edward Winslow's letter printed in Mourt's Relation (London, 1622), in Pilgrim Hall Museum's transcription | Pilgrim Hall Museum, Plimoth Patuxet Museums United States, England | 1621, 1622 | Winslow wrote that after the harvest the governor sent four men "fowling," and in one day they killed as much fowl as fed the colony for almost a week. Massasoit, the Wampanoag leader, came with about 90 men, and they killed five deer for the English leaders. Pilgrim Hall Museum says Winslow and Bradford are the only two primary sources for that fall. Plimoth Patuxet notes this one eyewitness account mentions just two foods: venison and wildfowl. | The letter never names the kind of birds, and it describes three days of feasting in one sentence, not a menu. | Pilgrim Hall Museum Plimoth Patuxet Museums |
| Reading of the primary text: William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation, in Pilgrim Hall Museum's transcription, plus a November 1621 letter from a newly arrived colonist | Pilgrim Hall Museum, Plimoth Patuxet Museums United States | 1621, 1630 | Describing the fall of 1621, Bradford wrote that besides waterfowl there was "great store of wild turkeys, of which they took many, besides venison." William Hilton, who arrived on the ship Fortune that November, wrote home about "great flocks of turkey." So turkeys were plentiful and the colonists were hunting them the same season as the feast. | Bradford wrote at least a decade later, and he describes the whole season without mentioning the feast at all. Hilton arrived just after the feast and did not attend it. | Pilgrim Hall Museum Plimoth Patuxet Museums |
| Review of published assessments by historians at Plimoth Patuxet Museums, the living-history museum at Plymouth, including one quoted by Smithsonian magazine | Plimoth Patuxet Museums, Smithsonian magazine United States | 2011, 2024, 2026 | Plimoth Patuxet's teaching pages say turkey at the feast "seems very likely" and is "probable," because writers of the time counted turkeys as fowl and Bradford reports many taken that fall. Kathleen Wall, a Plimoth Patuxet food historian, told Smithsonian that turkey was possible but not the centerpiece; she suspects goose or duck was the bird of choice. | These are informed judgments from one institution's staff, not new evidence. Their "very likely" rests mainly on Bradford's line and on what "fowl" meant then, so it does not add a separate line of proof. The museum's own pages range from "probable" to "almost certain." | Plimoth Patuxet Museums Plimoth Patuxet Museums Plimoth Patuxet Museums Smithsonian magazine |
| Review of food-history research by Plimoth Patuxet staff, as published by the museum and Smithsonian magazine | Plimoth Patuxet Museums, Smithsonian magazine United States | 2011, 2024, 2026 | Kathleen Wall calls wildfowl, corn and venison "absolutes." Corn was eaten as bread or porridge. Eels and shellfish such as lobster, clams and mussels were probably served, and sources from that fall note plentiful cod and sea bass. Birds may have been stuffed, though probably not with bread. | Apart from deer and fowl, these items are inferred from what was in season and from later records, not from an account of the meal. | Smithsonian magazine Plimoth Patuxet Museums |
| Review of food-history research by Plimoth Patuxet staff on when foods reached English and New England kitchens | Plimoth Patuxet Museums, Smithsonian magazine United States, England | 1621, 2026 | Today's classic dinner includes turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie. Potatoes had crossed the Atlantic by 1621 but were not yet part of the English diet. Pumpkin was likely served, but not as pie: the colony probably lacked enough butter and wheat flour for crust. The first printed cranberry sauce recipe came about half a century later. | Absence is inferred from what the colony had and from cookbooks of the period. No 1621 record lists what was missing. | Smithsonian magazine Plimoth Patuxet Museums |
| Reading of the 1841 book that first called the feast the first Thanksgiving, and of Plimoth Patuxet's history of turkey in Thanksgiving lore | Internet Archive, Plimoth Patuxet Museums United States | 1623, 1827, 1841 | In 1827 Sarah Josepha Hale, who later campaigned for a national Thanksgiving, described roast turkey at the head of the table. In 1841 Boston minister Alexander Young printed Winslow's letter and footnoted it as the first Thanksgiving, adding that they "no doubt feasted on the wild turkey." Turkey was a real gift food then: Massasoit brought one to Governor Bradford's wedding in 1623. | Young's footnote is a guess shaped by the holiday of his own time, not evidence about 1621. | Internet Archive Plimoth Patuxet Museums |
| State wildlife agency news release (November 2024) on the history and restoration of wild turkeys in Massachusetts | Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife United States | 1620, 1851, 1972, 2024 | The state wildlife agency says wild turkeys were found across most of Massachusetts when the Pilgrims arrived. They were rare by 1800 and gone by 1851. In the early 1970s, 37 birds trapped in New York were released in the Berkshires. As of 2024 the agency estimated about 30,000 to 35,000. | This is a news release from the agency that ran the restoration, and it describes where turkeys lived, not what was eaten at the feast. Its own fun-fact line overstates what the Pilgrims' writings say. | Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife |
1. The only eyewitness letter names deer and fowl, not turkey Reading of the primary text: Edward Winslow's letter printed in Mourt's Relation (London, 1622), in Pilgrim Hall Museum's transcription
Winslow wrote that after the harvest the governor sent four men "fowling," and in one day they killed as much fowl as fed the colony for almost a week. Massasoit, the Wampanoag leader, came with about 90 men, and they killed five deer for the English leaders. Pilgrim Hall Museum says Winslow and Bradford are the only two primary sources for that fall. Plimoth Patuxet notes this one eyewitness account mentions just two foods: venison and wildfowl.
Limit: The letter never names the kind of birds, and it describes three days of feasting in one sentence, not a menu.
Verify: Primary Sources for "The First Thanksgiving" at Plymouth What did they eat at the 1621 harvest celebration?
- Winslow wrote that four men sent fowling killed in one day as much fowl as fed the colony almost a week. He does not name the birds. Pilgrim Hall Museum · Qualifies
- Massasoit came with some ninety men, who killed five deer and gave them to the English leaders. Pilgrim Hall Museum · Qualifies
- Only two primary sources describe the events of autumn 1621 in Plymouth: Winslow and Bradford. Pilgrim Hall Museum · Qualifies
- The only eyewitness account mentions just two foods, venison and wildfowl, and says nothing of other dishes. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
2. The governor's history says they took many wild turkeys that fall Reading of the primary text: William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation, in Pilgrim Hall Museum's transcription, plus a November 1621 letter from a newly arrived colonist
Describing the fall of 1621, Bradford wrote that besides waterfowl there was "great store of wild turkeys, of which they took many, besides venison." William Hilton, who arrived on the ship Fortune that November, wrote home about "great flocks of turkey." So turkeys were plentiful and the colonists were hunting them the same season as the feast.
Limit: Bradford wrote at least a decade later, and he describes the whole season without mentioning the feast at all. Hilton arrived just after the feast and did not attend it.
Verify: Primary Sources for "The First Thanksgiving" at Plymouth Excerpt from William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation - Harvest of 1621
- Bradford wrote that fowl abounded that fall but later decreased, and that besides waterfowl the colonists took many wild turkeys, besides venison. Pilgrim Hall Museum
- William Hilton, who arrived on the Fortune in November 1621, wrote home about great flocks of turkey around the colony. He was not at the feast. Pilgrim Hall Museum
- Bradford wrote at least a decade later and did not mention the harvest celebration itself. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
3. Museum historians judge turkey very likely, but not the main dish Review of published assessments by historians at Plimoth Patuxet Museums, the living-history museum at Plymouth, including one quoted by Smithsonian magazine
Plimoth Patuxet's teaching pages say turkey at the feast "seems very likely" and is "probable," because writers of the time counted turkeys as fowl and Bradford reports many taken that fall. Kathleen Wall, a Plimoth Patuxet food historian, told Smithsonian that turkey was possible but not the centerpiece; she suspects goose or duck was the bird of choice.
Limit: These are informed judgments from one institution's staff, not new evidence. Their "very likely" rests mainly on Bradford's line and on what "fowl" meant then, so it does not add a separate line of proof. The museum's own pages range from "probable" to "almost certain."
Verify: "Great store of wild turkeys…" What did they eat at the 1621 harvest celebration? Excerpt from William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation - Harvest of 1621 What Food Was Served at the First Thanksgiving in 1621?
- The museum says it cannot be sure turkey was served in 1621, but that it seems very likely. Plimoth Patuxet Museums
- In the 1600s, writers counted turkeys as fowl, so Winslow's fowling party could have taken turkeys. Plimoth Patuxet Museums
- The museum's food historians call turkey at the feast probable, citing Bradford's great store of wild turkeys. Plimoth Patuxet Museums
- This museum page calls turkey at the feast likely or almost certain, citing Bradford. Plimoth Patuxet Museums
- Wall says turkey was not the centerpiece; wild turkey is possible, but she suspects goose or duck was the wildfowl of choice. Smithsonian magazine · Qualifies
5. What wasn't there: potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie Review of food-history research by Plimoth Patuxet staff on when foods reached English and New England kitchens
Today's classic dinner includes turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie. Potatoes had crossed the Atlantic by 1621 but were not yet part of the English diet. Pumpkin was likely served, but not as pie: the colony probably lacked enough butter and wheat flour for crust. The first printed cranberry sauce recipe came about half a century later.
Limit: Absence is inferred from what the colony had and from cookbooks of the period. No 1621 record lists what was missing.
Verify: What Food Was Served at the First Thanksgiving in 1621? What did they eat at the 1621 harvest celebration?
- Today's traditional dinner includes turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, candied yams, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie. Smithsonian magazine · Qualifies
- Potatoes had crossed the Atlantic by 1621 but were not yet part of the English diet. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
- Pumpkin was very likely served but not as pie: the colony probably lacked enough butter and wheat flour for crust, and the earliest written pumpkin pie recipes came after 1621. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
- Cranberries were a seasonal native fruit, but a printed recipe for cranberry sauce came about half a century after 1621. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
6. Turkey's starring role came from the 1800s Reading of the 1841 book that first called the feast the first Thanksgiving, and of Plimoth Patuxet's history of turkey in Thanksgiving lore
In 1827 Sarah Josepha Hale, who later campaigned for a national Thanksgiving, described roast turkey at the head of the table. In 1841 Boston minister Alexander Young printed Winslow's letter and footnoted it as the first Thanksgiving, adding that they "no doubt feasted on the wild turkey." Turkey was a real gift food then: Massasoit brought one to Governor Bradford's wedding in 1623.
Limit: Young's footnote is a guess shaped by the holiday of his own time, not evidence about 1621.
Verify: Alexander Young, Chronicles of the Pilgrim Fathers of the Colony of Plymouth, from 1602 to 1625 (Boston, 1841) "Great store of wild turkeys…"
- Young's footnote called the feast the first Thanksgiving and assumed they 'no doubt' ate wild turkey as well as venison. Internet Archive · Qualifies
- In 1827 Sarah Josepha Hale described roast turkey at the head of the Thanksgiving table. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
- In 1841 Alexander Young printed the eyewitness account and footnoted the event as the first Thanksgiving. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
- At Governor Bradford's wedding in August 1623, Massasoit (Ousamequin) brought a turkey along with deer. Plimoth Patuxet Museums
7. State wildlife agency: turkeys common in 1620, gone by 1851, back today State wildlife agency news release (November 2024) on the history and restoration of wild turkeys in Massachusetts
The state wildlife agency says wild turkeys were found across most of Massachusetts when the Pilgrims arrived. They were rare by 1800 and gone by 1851. In the early 1970s, 37 birds trapped in New York were released in the Berkshires. As of 2024 the agency estimated about 30,000 to 35,000.
Limit: This is a news release from the agency that ran the restoration, and it describes where turkeys lived, not what was eaten at the feast. Its own fun-fact line overstates what the Pilgrims' writings say.
Verify: Gobbling up the spotlight: The conservation comeback of wild turkeys
- When the Pilgrims arrived in 1620, wild turkeys were found throughout most of Massachusetts. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife
- Turkeys were rare in Massachusetts by 1800 and gone by 1851. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
- In the early 1970s, 37 wild turkeys trapped in New York were released in southern Berkshire County. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
- Massachusetts now has an estimated 30,000 to 35,000 wild turkeys. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
Common questions 7
“Turkey was the main dish at the first Thanksgiving.”
Short answer: No record says so
No record says turkey was the main dish; the only eyewitness letter names five deer and a week's worth of wildfowl. Turkey may have been among the birds, but a Plimoth Patuxet food historian thinks goose or duck was the main bird. Venison is the one meat the record names by kind.
- Massasoit came with some ninety men, who killed five deer and gave them to the English leaders. Pilgrim Hall Museum · Qualifies
- Winslow wrote that four men sent fowling killed in one day as much fowl as fed the colony almost a week. He does not name the birds. Pilgrim Hall Museum · Qualifies
- Wall says turkey was not the centerpiece; wild turkey is possible, but she suspects goose or duck was the wildfowl of choice. Smithsonian magazine · Qualifies
See the evidence: The only eyewitness letter names deer and fowl, not turkey
“The Pilgrims called their 1621 feast the first Thanksgiving.”
Short answer: No, that label dates from 1841
No: Boston minister Alexander Young first called the 1621 feast "the first Thanksgiving" in an 1841 book, 220 years later. Neither eyewitness Edward Winslow nor Governor William Bradford used the word for the feast. Young's same footnote guessed they "no doubt feasted on the wild turkey."
- Young's footnote called the feast the first Thanksgiving and assumed they 'no doubt' ate wild turkey as well as venison. Internet Archive · Qualifies
- In 1841 Alexander Young printed the eyewitness account and footnoted the event as the first Thanksgiving. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
See the evidence: Turkey's starring role came from the 1800s
“Today's wild turkeys in Massachusetts descend from the flocks the Pilgrims hunted.”
Short answer: No, they came from New York
Wild turkeys disappeared from Massachusetts by 1851, and today's flocks, about 30,000 to 35,000 as of 2024, grew from 37 birds brought from New York in the early 1970s. Bradford hinted at the decline: he wrote that fowl "afterward decreased by degrees."
- Turkeys were rare in Massachusetts by 1800 and gone by 1851. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
- In the early 1970s, 37 wild turkeys trapped in New York were released in southern Berkshire County. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
- Massachusetts now has an estimated 30,000 to 35,000 wild turkeys. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
- Bradford wrote that fowl abounded that fall but later decreased, and that besides waterfowl the colonists took many wild turkeys, besides venison. Pilgrim Hall Museum
See the evidence: State wildlife agency: turkeys common in 1620, gone by 1851, back today
“Bradford wrote that they took many wild turkeys, so turkey at the feast is proven.”
Short answer: Strong hint, not proof
No. Bradford's line describes the whole fall, written at least a decade later, and never mentions the feast. He says the fowl came in "as winter approached," and no account gives the feast's exact date, so some turkeys may have been taken after it. His "besides waterfowl" does show he counted turkeys apart from ducks and geese. The line makes turkey at the feast likely, not certain.
- Bradford wrote that fowl abounded that fall but later decreased, and that besides waterfowl the colonists took many wild turkeys, besides venison. Pilgrim Hall Museum
- Bradford wrote at least a decade later and did not mention the harvest celebration itself. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
See the evidence: The governor's history says they took many wild turkeys that fall
“Massachusetts wildlife officials say turkey was served at the first Thanksgiving.”
Short answer: Yes, more firmly than the record
The state wildlife agency's fun-fact page says turkey "was served" and that the Pilgrims' journals call it one of many game birds that day. The two accounts don't say that: Winslow names only "fowl," and Bradford's turkeys are about the season, not the feast.
- The agency states that turkey was served at the first Thanksgiving as one of many game birds, more firmly than the primary accounts do. Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife · Qualifies
- Winslow wrote that four men sent fowling killed in one day as much fowl as fed the colony almost a week. He does not name the birds. Pilgrim Hall Museum · Qualifies
- Bradford wrote that fowl abounded that fall but later decreased, and that besides waterfowl the colonists took many wild turkeys, besides venison. Pilgrim Hall Museum
See the evidence: The only eyewitness letter names deer and fowl, not turkey
“Pumpkin pie was served at the first Thanksgiving.”
Short answer: Pumpkin probably, pie no
Pumpkins and other squash were very likely eaten in some form, but not as pie. The colony probably lacked enough butter and wheat flour for pie crust, and the earliest written pumpkin pie recipes came after 1621.
- Pumpkin was very likely served but not as pie: the colony probably lacked enough butter and wheat flour for crust, and the earliest written pumpkin pie recipes came after 1621. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
See the evidence: What wasn't there: potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie
“Cranberry sauce and mashed potatoes go back to the first Thanksgiving.”
Short answer: No
Cranberries grew wild nearby, but the first printed recipe for cranberry sauce came about half a century later. Potatoes had crossed the Atlantic by 1621 but were not yet part of the English diet.
- Cranberries were a seasonal native fruit, but a printed recipe for cranberry sauce came about half a century after 1621. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
- Potatoes had crossed the Atlantic by 1621 but were not yet part of the English diet. Plimoth Patuxet Museums · Qualifies
See the evidence: What wasn't there: potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie
Conclusion
The claim holds up better than many Thanksgiving myths, but it rests on inference, not a record. Edward Winslow, the only eyewitness who wrote about the feast, says four men went "fowling" and Wampanoag hunters brought five deer. He never names the birds. William Bradford, writing at least a decade later, says the colonists took "many" wild turkeys that fall, but he does not mention the feast at all.
Put together, the case for turkey is strong. Turkeys were common, the colonists were hunting them that season, and writers of the time counted turkeys as fowl. Massasoit brought a turkey as a gift to Bradford's wedding two years later. That is why historians at Plimoth Patuxet, the museum at Plymouth, call turkey very likely. We rate the claim Mostly true rather than True because no account places a turkey on the table. Our confidence is Moderate because the case depends on two short texts and one museum's interpretation.
What the evidence does not support is the modern picture of a roast turkey at the center of the meal. The one meat named by kind is venison. A Plimoth Patuxet food historian thinks ducks or geese were more likely the main birds. Turkey's starring role came later: Sarah Josepha Hale put roast turkey "at the head of the table" in 1827, and Alexander Young's 1841 footnote that coined "the first Thanksgiving" assumed the Pilgrims "no doubt" ate wild turkey.
So if someone says the Pilgrims ate turkey in 1621, they are probably right. If they say it was the star of the meal, or that it came with mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie, the record says otherwise.
How we checked
- Defined the claim as whether turkey was eaten at the three-day 1621 harvest feast at Plymouth, not whether it was the main dish.
- Read both primary accounts, Winslow's 1621 letter (Mourt's Relation, 1622) and Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation, in Pilgrim Hall Museum's transcriptions, and checked Winslow's passage against an 1841 printing on the Internet Archive.
- Read Plimoth Patuxet Museums' published research on the 1621 menu and on turkeys, and Smithsonian magazine's interview with a Plimoth Patuxet food historian.
- Checked the history of wild turkeys in Massachusetts with the state wildlife agency.
- Traced when the feast was first called the first Thanksgiving, in Alexander Young's 1841 book.
- Recorded limits: only two primary accounts exist, the later one was written at least a decade after the event, and most food-history judgments come from one museum.
Editorial note: Scope: this check rates whether turkey was eaten at the 1621 harvest feast. It does not cover the wider history of Thanksgiving, which other FactHub checks address. Quotes from the two primary accounts use Pilgrim Hall Museum's modern-spelling transcriptions. No external specialist review has been recorded.
Expert-review status
No external specialist review has been recorded.
Funding and conflicts
Funding: No external funding for this piece.
Ownership: Published by the FactHub Research Team.
Conflicts: None known.
Sources 7
Sources are labeled by kind, with what this fact check takes from each, so readers can check the evidence independently.
-
Other
Pilgrim Hall Museum.
Primary Sources for "The First Thanksgiving" at Plymouth
Transcriptions, in original and modern spelling, of Edward Winslow's account in Mourt's Relation (1622), William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation, and William Hilton's November 1621 letter.
Reliability: Pilgrim Hall Museum in Plymouth, Massachusetts, is a museum of Pilgrim history. The page reproduces the primary texts with citations to their printed editions.
-
Qualifies: Only two primary sources describe the events of autumn 1621 in Plymouth: Winslow and Bradford.
What the source says
There are 2 (and only 2) primary sources for the events of autumn 1621 in Plymouth
IntroductionNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Winslow wrote that four men sent fowling killed in one day as much fowl as fed the colony almost a week. He does not name the birds.
What the source says
our governor sent four men on fowling…they four in one day killed as much fowl, as with a little help beside, served the Company almost a week
Edward Winslow, Mourt's Relation, modern spellingNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Massasoit came with some ninety men, who killed five deer and gave them to the English leaders.
What the source says
amongst the rest their greatest king Massasoit, with some ninety men, whom for three days we entertained and feasted, and they went out and killed five Deer, which they brought to the Plantation and bestowed on our Governor
Edward Winslow, Mourt's Relation, modern spellingNot yet checked
-
Bradford wrote that fowl abounded that fall but later decreased, and that besides waterfowl the colonists took many wild turkeys, besides venison.
What the source says
now began to come in store of fowl, as winter approached, of which this place did abound when they came first (but afterward decreased by degrees). And besides waterfowl there was great store of wild turkeys, of which they took many, besides venison, etc.
William Bradford, Of Plymouth Plantation, modern spellingNot yet checked
-
William Hilton, who arrived on the Fortune in November 1621, wrote home about great flocks of turkey around the colony. He was not at the feast.
What the source says
great flocks of turkey, quails, pigeons and partridges
Letter of William Hilton, November 1621Not yet checked
-
-
Other
Plimoth Patuxet Museums.
"Great store of wild turkeys…"
Teaching page by the living-history museum at Plymouth on turkeys in 17th-century New England and whether turkey was at the 1621 feast.
Reliability: Plimoth Patuxet is a nonprofit museum that recreates the 1620s English colony and a Wampanoag homesite. Its page cites period writers, archaeology and the primary accounts in footnotes.
-
The museum says it cannot be sure turkey was served in 1621, but that it seems very likely.
What the source says
But was turkey really on the table in 1621? Although we can’t say for sure, it seems very likely.
IntroductionNot yet checked
-
In the 1600s, writers counted turkeys as fowl, so Winslow's fowling party could have taken turkeys.
What the source says
Period writers considered turkeys to be fowl.
Paragraph on the 1621 harvest celebrationNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: In 1827 Sarah Josepha Hale described roast turkey at the head of the Thanksgiving table.
What the source says
In 1827, when Thanksgiving advocate Sarah Josepha Hale wrote what is thought to be the first literary description of Thanksgiving, she gave roasted turkey “precedence on this occasion, being placed at the head of the table.”
IntroductionNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: In 1841 Alexander Young printed the eyewitness account and footnoted the event as the first Thanksgiving.
What the source says
In 1841, when Alexander Young included the eyewitness account of the 1621 harvest feast in his Chronicles of the Pilgrim Fathers, he footnoted the event as “the first Thanksgiving.”
IntroductionNot yet checked
-
At Governor Bradford's wedding in August 1623, Massasoit (Ousamequin) brought a turkey along with deer.
What the source says
At the wedding of Governor William and Alice Bradford in August 1623, Ousamequin brought a turkey, in addition to three or four bucks
Paragraph on Indigenous uses of turkeyNot yet checked
-
-
Other
Plimoth Patuxet Museums.
Excerpt from William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation - Harvest of 1621
Teaching page presenting Bradford's description of the 1621 harvest, from the State Library of Massachusetts' digitized manuscript, with the museum's commentary.
Reliability: Plimoth Patuxet is a nonprofit living-history museum at Plymouth. The excerpt is from Bradford's manuscript held by the State Library of Massachusetts.
-
This museum page calls turkey at the feast likely or almost certain, citing Bradford.
What the source says
It is likely or almost certain that the feast featured turkey.
CommentaryNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Bradford wrote at least a decade later and did not mention the harvest celebration itself.
What the source says
Many historians wonder why William Bradford, writing at least a decade later, did not mention the harvest celebration.
CommentaryNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Contemporary sources note plentiful cod and sea bass in the late summer and fall of 1621.
What the source says
Contemporary sources note the plentiful fish, including cod and sea bass, the communities enjoyed throughout the late summer and fall of 1621.
CommentaryNot yet checked
-
-
News report
Smithsonian magazine.
What Food Was Served at the First Thanksgiving in 1621?
Magazine article, first published in 2011 and updated in 2024, interviewing Plimoth Patuxet food historian Kathleen Wall about the 1621 menu.
Reliability: Smithsonian magazine is published by the Smithsonian Institution. The article relies mainly on one Plimoth Patuxet food historian, so it is not independent of the museum's other pages.
-
Qualifies: Kathleen Wall says wildfowl, corn (as bread or porridge) and venison were certainly there.
What the source says
Wildfowl was there. Corn, in grain form for bread or for porridge, was there. Venison was there,
Opening section · Kathleen Wall, foodways culinarian, Plimoth PatuxetNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Wall says turkey was not the centerpiece; wild turkey is possible, but she suspects goose or duck was the wildfowl of choice.
What the source says
Turkey was not the centerpiece of the meal, as it is today, explains Wall. Though it is possible the colonists and American Indians cooked wild turkey, she suspects that goose or duck was the wildfowl of choice.
Section on the birdNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: The colonists and Wampanoag probably ate eels and shellfish such as lobster, clams and mussels.
What the source says
In addition to wildfowl and deer, the colonists and Wampanoag probably ate eels and shellfish, such as lobster, clams and mussels.
Section on the birdNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Birds may have been stuffed, though probably not with bread.
What the source says
It is possible that the birds were stuffed, though probably not with bread.
Section on preparationNot yet checked
-
-
Other
Internet Archive.
Alexander Young, Chronicles of the Pilgrim Fathers of the Colony of Plymouth, from 1602 to 1625 (Boston, 1841)
Free copy
Scan of the 1841 book that reprinted Winslow's letter and first labeled the 1621 feast the first Thanksgiving, in a footnote on page 231.
Reliability: A digitized library copy of the original 1841 printing. Young was a Boston Unitarian minister and editor; his footnotes are his own interpretation, not 1621 evidence.
-
Qualifies: Young's footnote called the feast the first Thanksgiving and assumed they 'no doubt' ate wild turkey as well as venison.
What the source says
This was the first Thanksgiving, the harvest festival of New England. On this occasion they no doubt feasted on the wild turkey as well as venison.
p. 231, footnote 3Not yet checked
-
-
Government
Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife.
Gobbling up the spotlight: The conservation comeback of wild turkeys
State wildlife agency news release (November 4, 2024) on the history, disappearance and reintroduction of wild turkeys in Massachusetts.
Reliability: Has a stake in this finding. MassWildlife runs the state's wild turkey restoration and hunting seasons, so the release reports on its own program's success. Its history and population figures come from its own restoration records.
-
When the Pilgrims arrived in 1620, wild turkeys were found throughout most of Massachusetts.
What the source says
When the Pilgrims first arrived in Massachusetts in 1620, wild turkeys were found throughout most of the state.
HistoryNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Turkeys were rare in Massachusetts by 1800 and gone by 1851.
What the source says
By 1800, turkeys were quite rare in Massachusetts, and they had disappeared by 1851.
HistoryNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: In the early 1970s, 37 wild turkeys trapped in New York were released in southern Berkshire County.
What the source says
37 wild turkeys were live-trapped in southwestern New York and released in southern Berkshire County in the early 1970s.
Reintroduction effortsNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: Massachusetts now has an estimated 30,000 to 35,000 wild turkeys.
What the source says
The turkey population in Massachusetts is now estimated to be 30,000–35,000.
Turkeys todayNot yet checked
-
Qualifies: The agency states that turkey was served at the first Thanksgiving as one of many game birds, more firmly than the primary accounts do.
What the source says
Turkey was served at the first Thanksgiving, but it was not the center of the meal. According to the journals of Pilgrims, it was just one of many different game birds served that day.
Fun facts about turkeysNot yet checked
-
Update history 1 change, last
- Initial draft.
Cited by
For developers: ClaimReview data
This page includes standardized ClaimReview metadata describing the exact claim, FactHub's finding, publisher, and review dates. You can inspect the record below and confirm that it matches the article you just read.
View ClaimReview JSON
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"ClaimReview","url":"https://facthub.org/n/article/pilgrims-turkey-first-thanksgiving","datePublished":"2026-11-17","dateModified":"2026-11-17","author":{"@type":"Organization","name":"FactHub","url":"https://facthub.org/"},"claimReviewed":"The Pilgrims ate turkey at the first Thanksgiving in 1621.","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","alternateName":"Mostly true"},"image":"https://facthub.org/node-assets-v2/article/pilgrims-turkey-first-thanksgiving/1/wild-turkey/social-1200x630.jpg"}
This metadata helps machines discover the fact-check. It does not prove the conclusion or guarantee special treatment by a search engine.
Challenge this fact-check
Every source above is linked so you can check it yourself. Identify the specific conclusion you dispute and provide verifiable evidence that could change it. Credible challenges deserve review and a visible response.
Submit evidence Send general feedback insteadTechnical details: node handle article:pilgrims-turkey-first-thanksgiving:1