Chart
When FDR moved Thanksgiving in 1939, the states split almost in half
Which Thanksgiving each state's governor proclaimed in 1939: President Roosevelt's Nov. 23, the traditional last Thursday (Nov. 30), or both.
Credit: FactHub Research Team; state list from Prologue (National Archives), Fall 1990
Where this chart is used
What this chart asks
How many states followed President Roosevelt's earlier Thanksgiving date in 1939?
Why it is shown this way
- A map lets readers find their own state; equal circles colored by date show the split without implying size.
- The fallback stacked count shows the 22 / 23 / 3 split.
Data and accessibility
The chart's data and images are in the strip under it.
Dataset national-thanksgiving-proclamations,
analysis map-1939
Sources
This chart draws on the sources of the dataset versions it visualizes.
U.S. national days of thanksgiving, 1777-1945, and the 1939 state split
-
The American Presidency Project, UC Santa Barbara: presidential proclamations
Full text of each presidential thanksgiving proclamation, 1789-1945, used for the signing date and the day named.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Transcriptions of public-domain documents. Underlying documents are public domain; we store only short phrases and dates
Reliability: Academic. An academic archive run by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley at UC Santa Barbara. It transcribes proclamations from the Statutes at Large and Messages and Papers of the Presidents. It has no stake in the date of Thanksgiving.
-
Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774-1789 (Library of Congress edition, 1904-37), scans on the Internet Archive
Congress's thanksgiving resolutions for 1777-1784 (volumes 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 23, 25 and 27; each row links its volume).
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability: Government. The official journal of the Continental and Confederation Congress, edited and printed by the Library of Congress. We read machine-read text of the scans, which has some character errors.
-
G. Wallace Chessman, "Thanksgiving: Another FDR Experiment," Prologue, Fall 1990 (National Archives)
Footnote 38 lists the date each of the 48 states observed in 1939, with its governor's party, from the New York Times of Oct. 17 and Nov. 23, 1939.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability: Government. Published in the National Archives' magazine, which says its articles don't necessarily represent the agency's views. The state list is the author's transcription of two New York Times tallies.
-
National Archives, Center for Legislative Archives: Congress Establishes Thanksgiving
Gives a different count for the 1939 split (32 states with the President, 16 against); recorded as a conflicting source.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability: Government. A short National Archives feature on the 1941 joint resolution. It does not list states or say which year its count describes.
-
U.S. Statutes at Large, vol. 55, p. 862: Joint resolution making the fourth Thursday in November a legal holiday (Dec. 26, 1941)
The law that fixed Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November from 1942 on.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability: Government. The official compilation of federal laws, scanned by the Library of Congress.
Limitations
- From a 1990 National Archives magazine article that transcribed two New York Times tallies; a separate National Archives page gives 32 states for the new date and 16 against, without naming states or a year.
- Circle size carries no value; every state is drawn the same size.
- Alaska and Hawaii were not states in 1939.
Where this chart is used: version details
The exact citing versions, and the version of this chart each cites.
-
Article
lincoln-thanksgiving-national-holiday— version 1 (published)cites version 1
Node: chart:thanksgiving-1939-state-split:1