What this dataset measures
The Seattle Times is Washington's largest daily newspaper and ran more staff news stories on I-638 than any other Washington outlet. This release records each item a two-coder review and a red-team pass flagged as departing from the measure's text, official statistics, peer-reviewed research or the paper's own later reporting, so readers can check every item and every count.
- Geography
- Washington, United States
- Unit of observation
- One coded statement (or headline) in one Seattle Times news story
- Update cadence
- One-time release; a new version will record any later corrections by the Times or challenges FactHub accepts.
- Curator
- FactHub Research Team
Saved analyses
How firmly the paper rebutted each side's central verification claim
Question: When the paper checked each side's strongest claim about verification in its own voice, did it rebut it flatly or with a hedge?
Result: The No side's genital-exam claim was checked in four stories, five hedged sentences, never flatly. The Yes side's strong-form claim got two flat rebuttals, which were accurate.
Operation: List own-voice checks of the No side's 'I-638 requires genital exams' claim and of the Yes side's 'sports physicals already confirm sex' claim, coded flat or hedged.
Scope: Six Seattle Times news stories, January 9 to October 30, 2026.
View this analysis
- Firmness is a reading of wording; the four hedged items are coded as framing rows B9, P2, P3 and B33. The flat rebuttals are accurate and are not counted as departures.
Sources
-
The Seattle Times
Primary record: the news stories whose wording is coded. Each row's url names its story.
Retrieved October 30, 2026. All rights reserved (The Seattle Times). Short quotations only, for criticism and review; full story text is not redistributed.
Reliability:
News report.
Washington's largest daily newspaper and the subject of this review. Its own published wording is the record being coded.
-
Washington Secretary of State
Reference record: the measure's filed text, used to check statements about what I-638 requires and whom it covers (Sections 1 and 3).
Retrieved October 30, 2026. Public record. Public government record; linked, not hosted.
Reliability:
Government.
Official filed text of Initiative Measure IL26-638 as published by the Secretary of State; the measure itself was written by its sponsors.
-
American Academy of Pediatrics
Reference record: what AAP well-visit guidelines list for girls aged 11-17, used to check statements about well visits.
Retrieved October 30, 2026. Copyright American Academy of Pediatrics. Linked, not hosted.
Reliability:
Academic.
The AAP's national guideline for preventive pediatric care (4th edition, 2017). The AAP opposes measures like I-638, but the guideline predates it and does not address sports.
-
Data Resource Center for Child and Adolescent Health (NSCH)
Reference record: Washington children without a personal doctor or nurse, 2023-24, used to check the paper's 18% figure.
Retrieved October 30, 2026. Public data. Linked, not hosted.
Reliability:
Government.
National Survey of Children's Health, funded by HRSA and fielded by the Census Bureau; query tool run by the Child and Adolescent Health Measurement Initiative.
-
Hilton & Lundberg, Sports Medicine
Reference record: review of strength and lean mass after testosterone suppression, used to check statements about the research.
Free copy
Retrieved October 30, 2026. CC BY 4.0. Linked, not hosted.
Reliability:
Peer-reviewed study.
Peer-reviewed narrative review (Sports Med 2021;51:199-214). The authors have argued publicly for protecting the female category.
-
Harper et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine
Reference record: systematic review of strength, lean mass and muscle area after hormone therapy.
Retrieved October 30, 2026. CC BY-NC 4.0. Linked, not hosted.
Reliability:
Peer-reviewed study.
Systematic review of 24 studies (Br J Sports Med 2021;55:865-872). Lead author Joanna Harper supports transgender inclusion and is quoted by the Times.
License: FactHub's selection, cleaning and combined tables are
licensed under CC BY 4.0.
Source data keeps the terms listed above (terms).
Limitations and reproducibility
Partially reproducible: Every coded item gives the story URL, the coded wording and what the record shows, so anyone can re-check each item and recount the tables. The coding judgments themselves (especially framing) cannot be recomputed mechanically. Pre-correction wording for three corrected items comes from Internet Archive captures or the paper's correction notes.
- Framing calls are judgments. Two independent coders and a red-team review reduce, but do not remove, the chance that another reader would code an item differently. Inter-coder agreement was not computed formally.
- Scope: 44 Seattle Times staff, partner and freelance news stories on I-638 or Washington trans athletes, January 2025 to October 30, 2026. Opinion pieces, letters and wire copy are excluded, so the 12-to-2 opinion-page balance against the measure is not counted here.
- Only items that depart from the record are listed. Accurate statements are not tallied, so the table measures the direction of errors and slanted framing, not their rate per sentence.
- Quotes the paper printed without checking are tallied separately as 'unchecked', because they are not the paper's own words. They split roughly evenly: 4 favored Yes and 3 favored No.
- Some pre-correction wording (for example the October 14, 2026 Camas story) comes from an Internet Archive capture and the paper's correction note, not from the current page.
- One story URL contains the name of a minor athlete; for that row (B7) the url field gives the section page instead.
- The Seattle Times was not asked to comment before publication.
Publications using this dataset
Version details
The exact citing versions, and the version of this dataset each cites.
-
Article
seattle-times-i638-coverage-departures —
version 9
(published) cites version 2
-
Article
seattle-times-i638-coverage-departures —
version 7
(published) cites version 2
-
Article
seattle-times-i638-coverage-departures —
version 6
(published) cites version 2
-
Article
seattle-times-i638-coverage-departures —
version 3
(published) cites version 2
-
Article
seattle-times-i638-coverage-departures —
version 2
(published) cites version 1
-
Article
seattle-times-i638-coverage-departures —
version 1
(published) cites version 1
-
Chart
seattle-times-i638-departures-by-side —
version 2
(published) cites version 2
-
Chart
seattle-times-i638-departures-by-side —
version 1
(published) cites version 1
Node: dataset:seattle-times-i638-departures:2:analysis:rebuttal-firmness