Coded statements
One row per coded statement in a Washington newsroom’s news story about I-638, with where it sits in the claim grid and why.
Unit of observation: One statement printed in a news story
| statement_id | source_id | story_uid | canonical_story_uid | newsroom | printed_in | date | location | is_headline | voice | item_type | claim_code | question_key | question | placement | side_helped | whats_true | rating_article | correction | coding_source | quote_is_correction_note | reference_outlet |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| q-st01-1 | story-seattle-time-st01 | seattle-times:ST01 | seattle-times:ST01 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2025-06-11 | paragraph 41 | N | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
The resolution restricted female categories to "biological females"; it did not ban trans students from sports entirely (para 4).
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | corrected | coder | Y | N |
| q-st01-2 | story-seattle-time-st01 | seattle-times:ST01 | seattle-times:ST01 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2025-06-11 | paragraph 5 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Reported fact; consistent with WIAA statement that very few trans athletes are known statewide.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-hn01-1 | story-everett-hera-hn01 | everett-herald:HN01 | everett-herald:HN01 | WA State Standard | Everett Herald | 2025-06-12 | paragraph 9 | N | quote | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | yes |
WIAA counts about 10 trans athletes statewide; story gives no number or performance-gap figure.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st02-1 | story-seattle-time-st02 | seattle-times:ST02 | seattle-times:ST02 | WA State Standard | Seattle Times | 2025-06-12 | paragraph 8 | N | quote | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | yes |
p_gap/p_few/p_hrt triggered: fairness concern printed; no performance-gap number, no count of trans athletes, no hormone-rule context anywhere in story.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr250629a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr250629a | spokesman-review:SR250629a | spokesman-review:SR250629a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2025-06-29 | paragraph 21 | N | paraphrase | accurate | N510 | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA says it knows of no more than about 10 trans athletes; disclosure is not required.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr250815a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr250815a | spokesman-review:SR250815a | spokesman-review:SR250815a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2025-08-15 | paragraph 1 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA rule 18.16.0 and OSPI policy let students play in the category matching gender identity.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-co01-1 | story-columbian-co01 | columbian:CO01 | columbian:CO01 | WA State Standard | The Columbian | 2025-09-09 | paragraph 22 | N | paraphrase | unchecked | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Wrong, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(2): own provider, any one of three bases; no exam named.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr250918a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr250918a | spokesman-review:SR250918a | spokesman-review:SR250918a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2025-09-18 | paragraph 20 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WA anti-discrimination law and WIAA 18.16.0 allowed participation by gender identity before I-638.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr251005a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr251005a | spokesman-review:SR251005a | spokesman-review:SR251005a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2025-10-05 | paragraph 19 | N | own | accurate | N510 | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA estimate; disclosure not required.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts02-1 | story-the-stranger-ts02 | the-stranger:TS02 | the-stranger:TS02 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-10-08 | paragraph 2 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
'Anti-trans' is the No side's characterization; the measure restricts female-only competition.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-sr251120a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr251120a | spokesman-review:SR251120a | spokesman-review:SR251120a | Olympian (McClatchy) | Spokesman-Review | 2025-11-20 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: the No coalition (Washington Families for Freedom; WEA and ACLU-WA donors) gets no political label.
|
— | unknown | merge coder | N | N |
| q-sr251120a-2 | story-spokesman-re-sr251120a | spokesman-review:SR251120a | spokesman-review:SR251120a | Olympian (McClatchy) | Spokesman-Review | 2025-11-20 | paragraph 11 | N | own | accurate | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Right | neutral |
Matches Sec. 3(2): own provider, any one of three bases.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | unknown | merge coder | N | N |
| q-sr251120a-3 | story-spokesman-re-sr251120a | spokesman-review:SR251120a | spokesman-review:SR251120a | Olympian (McClatchy) | Spokesman-Review | 2025-11-20 | paragraph 4 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Matches Sec. 3(1): girls-only competition.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | unknown | merge coder | N | N |
| q-ts04-1 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 10 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
LGW says the sports measure protects fairness and safety in female competition; 'targets ... kids' is the No side's characterization.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-2 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 3 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA's gender-identity rule dates to 2007-08 and was in force until I-638.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-3 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 41 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
No side's characterization presented in own voice ('A sore loser' in same sentence).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-4 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 41 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_fund trigger; No-side funding (WA Families for Freedom backers) not named. p_lab trigger: 'Conservatives', 'right-wing nonprofit', 'right-wing commentator'; No coalition unlabeled.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-5 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 46 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-6 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 46 | N | own | misleading | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(2) asks the girl's own health care provider to verify sex relying on any one of reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or endogenous testosterone; no exam or procedure is named.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-7 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 5 | N | own | misleading | NNOEDGE | edge | Do trans girls keep an athletic edge? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Male-female performance gaps of roughly 10-12% in running/swimming are well documented; studies of trans women after testosterone suppression find some advantages retained; WA required no hormone treatment.
|
trans-girls-athletic-advantage | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-8 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 5 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | neutral |
p_gap trigger (para 3 injury fear; para 61 'lack of fairness'): no performance-gap number given (fail). p_few pass: this phrase. p_hrt trigger (this para on advantage): no hormone/puberty context (fail).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts04-9 | story-the-stranger-ts04 | the-stranger:TS04 | the-stranger:TS04 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2025-12-02 | paragraph 9 | N | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
State laws (e.g., Idaho, West Virginia) bar trans girls from girls' teams; boys'/coed teams remain open.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-co02-1 | story-columbian-co02 | columbian:CO02 | columbian:CO02 | The Columbian | The Columbian | 2025-12-11 | paragraph 2 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Describes the 2025 WIAA amendment structure (boys/open vs girls-only).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st05-1 | story-seattle-time-st05 | seattle-times:ST05 | columbian:CO03 | WA State Standard | Seattle Times | 2026-01-03 | paragraph 4 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) applies to female-only competition.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | rerun copy | N | N |
| q-ts05-1 | story-the-stranger-ts05 | the-stranger:TS05 | the-stranger:TS05 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-01-05 | paragraph 27 | N | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts05-2 | story-the-stranger-ts05 | the-stranger:TS05 | the-stranger:TS05 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-01-05 | paragraph 27 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
'Anti-LGBTQ' is the No side's characterization.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-st06-1 | story-seattle-time-st06 | seattle-times:ST06 | seattle-times:ST06 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-09 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: Yes side labeled "conservative-backed"; No coalition never labeled.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st06-2 | story-seattle-time-st06 | seattle-times:ST06 | seattle-times:ST06 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-09 | paragraph 8 | N | quote | hedged_check | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Wrong, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(2): the girl's own provider verifies sex using any one of anatomy, genetics or testosterone; no exam is named; no age floor.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st06-3 | story-seattle-time-st06 | seattle-times:ST06 | seattle-times:ST06 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-09 | paragraph 9 | N | own | hedged_check | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Measure requires a provider statement verifying biological sex based on anatomy, genetics or testosterone (Sec. 3(2)); it does not mention sex assigned at birth or birth documentation.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-co04-1 | story-columbian-co04 | columbian:CO04 | columbian:CO04 | WA State Standard | The Columbian | 2026-01-12 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
No coalition unlabeled.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st07-1 | story-seattle-time-st07 | seattle-times:ST07 | seattle-times:ST07 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-13 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: Yes-side group labeled conservative (also para 5 "conservative groups"); no No-side coalition appears or is labeled.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-hn04-1 | story-everett-hera-hn04 | everett-herald:HN04 | everett-herald:HN04 | Everett Herald | Everett Herald | 2026-01-14 | paragraph 3 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Matches pre-I-638 WIAA rule 18.16.0 (participation by gender identity).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260115a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr260115a | spokesman-review:SR260115a | spokesman-review:SR260115a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-01-15 | paragraph 9 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA adopted its gender-identity participation rule in 2007, effective 2008.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-co06-1 | story-columbian-co06 | columbian:CO06 | columbian:CO06 | The Columbian | The Columbian | 2026-01-16 | paragraph 1 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Attributed accurately to the federal release; pre-I-638 WIAA rule allowed participation by gender identity.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-co07-1 | story-columbian-co07 | columbian:CO07 | seattle-times:ST08 | The Columbian | The Columbian | 2026-01-23 | its headline | Y | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) covers female-only competition only; trans girls can still play on boys or open teams.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | rerun headline | — | N |
| q-st08-1 | story-seattle-time-st08 | seattle-times:ST08 | seattle-times:ST08 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-23 | paragraph 10 | N | quote | hedged_check | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Wrong, helped No | no |
No exam is named; testosterone or genetics are alternatives (Sec. 3(2)); no age floor.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st08-2 | story-seattle-time-st08 | seattle-times:ST08 | seattle-times:ST08 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-23 | paragraph 11 | N | own | hedged_check | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Accurate as far as it goes; Sec. 3(2) lists anatomy, genetics or testosterone, any one sufficing.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st08-3 | story-seattle-time-st08 | seattle-times:ST08 | seattle-times:ST08 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-23 | paragraph 3 | N | own | misleading | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | neutral |
Sec. 3(2) requires a provider-signed form verifying biological sex from anatomy, genetics or testosterone; it does not refer to sex assigned at birth or birth documents.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st08-4 | story-seattle-time-st08 | seattle-times:ST08 | seattle-times:ST08 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-23 | paragraph 4 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: Yes labeled conservative (also paras 7, 19); No coalition members listed (incl. SEIU 775) but not labeled -> partial.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st08-5 | story-seattle-time-st08 | seattle-times:ST08 | seattle-times:ST08 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-01-23 | its headline | Y | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) covers female-only competition only; trans girls can still play on boys or open teams.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | reconciled | — | N |
| q-sr260123a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr260123a | spokesman-review:SR260123a | seattle-times:ST08 | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-01-23 | its headline | Y | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) covers female-only competition only; trans girls can still play on boys or open teams.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | rerun headline | — | N |
| q-yh260123a-1 | story-yakima-heral-yh260123a | yakima-herald:YH260123a | seattle-times:ST08 | Yakima Herald-Republic | Yakima Herald-Republic | 2026-01-23 | its headline | Y | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) covers female-only competition only; trans girls can still play on boys or open teams.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | rerun headline | — | N |
| q-ts06-1 | story-the-stranger-ts06 | the-stranger:TS06 | the-stranger:TS06 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-02-02 | paragraph 23 | N | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts06-2 | story-the-stranger-ts06 | the-stranger:TS06 | the-stranger:TS06 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-02-02 | paragraph 23 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
Satirical own-voice attribution of motive; measure's stated purpose is fairness/safety in female sports.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-co08-1 | story-columbian-co08 | columbian:CO08 | columbian:CO08 | WA State Standard | The Columbian | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 10 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
No coalition unlabeled.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-co08-2 | story-columbian-co08 | columbian:CO08 | columbian:CO08 | WA State Standard | The Columbian | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 21 | N | paraphrase | unchecked | YDOC | checkbox | Can a doctor’s checkbox confirm a girl’s sex? | Right | yes |
WIAA physical form records sex but does not verify it; I-638 adds a provider verification.
|
wa-i638-yes-campaign-claims | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st09-1 | story-seattle-time-st09 | seattle-times:ST09 | seattle-times:ST09 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 19 | N | own | misleading | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
Associations do endorse such care, but systematic reviews (e.g., UK Cass Review 2024, HHS review 2025) rated the youth evidence low certainty; "decades of evidence ... significantly improves" overstates it.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st09-2 | story-seattle-time-st09 | seattle-times:ST09 | seattle-times:ST09 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 21 | N | own | misleading | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
A Dec. 2025 Rogers High (Puyallup) girls' wrestling incident was reported as a sexual assault by a trans competitor and led to mandatory-reporter charges against school officials (ST Aug. 3, 2026); prosecutors declined to charge the student, so "no confirmed" is technically defensible but omits the reported incident.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st09-3 | story-seattle-time-st09 | seattle-times:ST09 | seattle-times:ST09 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 22 | N | paraphrase | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Boys' and open teams unaffected (Sec. 3(1)).
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st09-4 | story-seattle-time-st09 | seattle-times:ST09 | seattle-times:ST09 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 23 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: Yes labeled conservative (also LGW para 5 "conservative political committee"); No coalition members named incl. SEIU 775 (para 26), not labeled -> partial.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st09-5 | story-seattle-time-st09 | seattle-times:ST09 | seattle-times:ST09 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-02-04 | paragraph 3 | N | own | misleading | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | neutral |
Sec. 3(2): provider verifies biological sex via anatomy, genetics or testosterone; no birth documentation.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts07-1 | story-the-stranger-ts07 | the-stranger:TS07 | the-stranger:TS07 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-02-05 | paragraph 22 | N | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts07-2 | story-the-stranger-ts07 | the-stranger:TS07 | the-stranger:TS07 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-02-05 | paragraph 22 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
Characterization of Yes-side testimony in own voice; none of it quoted.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-co09-1 | story-columbian-co09 | columbian:CO09 | seattle-times:ST10 | Seattle Times | The Columbian | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 2 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(2).
|
— | not corrected | rerun copy | N | N |
| q-st10-1 | story-seattle-time-st10 | seattle-times:ST10 | seattle-times:ST10 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 2 | N | own | framing | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(2) places verification "as part of the required routine sports physical examination" by the girl's own provider, with any one of three bases; no exam is mandated.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st10-2 | story-seattle-time-st10 | seattle-times:ST10 | seattle-times:ST10 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 7 | N | own | accurate | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Right | neutral |
Matches Sec. 3(2).
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st10-3 | story-seattle-time-st10 | seattle-times:ST10 | seattle-times:ST10 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 7 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_fund and p_lab triggered; no No-side funding or label anywhere in story.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st10-4 | story-seattle-time-st10 | seattle-times:ST10 | seattle-times:ST10 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 8 | N | own | accurate | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Right | neutral |
Anatomy is one of three permitted bases; the story gives the alternatives in the same passage (p_doc pass).
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st10-5 | story-seattle-time-st10 | seattle-times:ST10 | seattle-times:ST10 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 9 | N | paraphrase | flat_check | YDOC | checkbox | Can a doctor’s checkbox confirm a girl’s sex? | Right | no |
Pediatricians correctly say physicals include no blood tests or pelvic exams; but the AAP preparticipation (PPE) history form that WIAA posts asks the athlete's sex, which the story does not mention.
|
wa-i638-yes-campaign-claims | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts08-1 | story-the-stranger-ts08 | the-stranger:TS08 | the-stranger:TS08 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 5 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
Segment headline adopts No-side label.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts08-2 | story-the-stranger-ts08 | the-stranger:TS08 | the-stranger:TS08 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 5 | N | own | misleading | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts08-3 | story-the-stranger-ts08 | the-stranger:TS08 | the-stranger:TS08 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 5 | N | own | misleading | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(2) asks the girl's own health care provider to verify sex relying on any one of reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or endogenous testosterone; no exam or procedure is named.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts08-4 | story-the-stranger-ts08 | the-stranger:TS08 | the-stranger:TS08 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-03-05 | paragraph 5 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_fund and p_lab triggers; no No-side funding or label.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-sr260312a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr260312a | spokesman-review:SR260312a | spokesman-review:SR260312a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-03-12 | paragraph 16 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | yes |
Political label applied to the Yes sponsor only; No coalition not described in this passing mention.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st11-1 | story-seattle-time-st11 | seattle-times:ST11 | seattle-times:ST11 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-04-18 | paragraph 35 | N | paraphrase | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Small numbers consistent with WIAA (about 10 in WA).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st12-1 | story-seattle-time-st12 | seattle-times:ST12 | seattle-times:ST12 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-05-12 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: Yes labeled conservative/right-wing repeatedly; the complainant group is not characterized politically.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts09-1 | story-the-stranger-ts09 | the-stranger:TS09 | the-stranger:TS09 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-05-13 | paragraph 3 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts09-2 | story-the-stranger-ts09 | the-stranger:TS09 | the-stranger:TS09 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-05-13 | paragraph 8 | N | paraphrase | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_fund trigger; No-side funding not given. p_lab trigger ('Right-wing podcaster', 'conservative organization'); No coalition not labeled.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts09-3 | story-the-stranger-ts09 | the-stranger:TS09 | the-stranger:TS09 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-05-13 | its headline | Y | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
'Anti-trans' is the No side's label for a measure restricting female-only competition.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-co10-1 | story-columbian-co10 | columbian:CO10 | columbian:CO10 | WA State Standard | The Columbian | 2026-06-19 | paragraph 8 | N | quote | unchecked | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Wrong, helped No | no |
Sec. 3(2): own provider, any one of three bases; no exam named.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-hn05-1 | story-everett-hera-hn05 | everett-herald:HN05 | columbian:CO10 | WA State Standard | Everett Herald | 2026-06-20 | paragraph 8 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(2): verification is part of the required routine sports physical.
|
— | not corrected | rerun copy | N | N |
| q-st13-1 | story-seattle-time-st13 | seattle-times:ST13 | seattle-times:ST13 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 18 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA: no more than about 10 known; disclosure not required.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st13-2 | story-seattle-time-st13 | seattle-times:ST13 | seattle-times:ST13 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 22 | N | own | misleading | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | neutral |
Sec. 3(2): provider verifies biological sex via anatomy, genetics or testosterone; no birth documentation.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st13-3 | story-seattle-time-st13 | seattle-times:ST13 | seattle-times:ST13 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 23 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: Yes labeled conservative; No Hate's backers (NEA, ACLU-WA, WEA) listed but not labeled -> partial.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st13-4 | story-seattle-time-st13 | seattle-times:ST13 | seattle-times:ST13 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 26 | N | quote | unchecked | NEXT | extreme | Is I-638 the most extreme law of its kind? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Other states (e.g., Idaho's 2020 law) included sex-verification provisions with dispute procedures; "most extreme" is an opinion the story leaves unexamined; "blanket" is contradicted by para 21 (girls teams only).
|
wa-i638-most-extreme | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260630a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 13 | N | own | accurate | N510 | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA estimate; disclosure not required.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260630a-2 | story-spokesman-re-sr260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 23 | N | paraphrase | unchecked | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
The Trevor Project survey reports state-level rates but does not show that sports bans drastically raise suicide rates; the causal claim is not checked in the story.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260630a-3 | story-spokesman-re-sr260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 29 | N | paraphrase | unchecked | OTHER | other | Other questions | Wrong, helped Yes | yes |
Polls showed majority support (I-638 passed with about 56.8%), well below 80-90%; no context given.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260630a-4 | story-spokesman-re-sr260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 33 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) covers female-only competition only.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260630a-5 | story-spokesman-re-sr260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | spokesman-review:SR260630a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-06-30 | paragraph 8 | N | own | false | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | neutral |
The Idaho law classifies by biological sex; the issue is gender identity, not sexual orientation.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st14-1 | story-seattle-time-st14 | seattle-times:ST14 | seattle-times:ST14 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-08-03 | paragraph 14 | N | own | accurate | OTHER | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
Reported fact; gives context on the assault allegation in both directions.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts11-1 | story-the-stranger-ts11 | the-stranger:TS11 | the-stranger:TS11 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-08-17 | paragraph 7 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
No-side label in own voice.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts12-1 | story-the-stranger-ts12 | the-stranger:TS12 | the-stranger:TS12 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-08-21 | paragraph 9 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
No-side label in own voice.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-st15-1 | story-seattle-time-st15 | seattle-times:ST15 | seattle-times:ST15 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-08-27 | paragraph 24 | N | quote | hedged_check | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Wrong, helped No | no |
No exam is mandated; the girl's own provider may use genetics or testosterone instead (Sec. 3(2)).
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st15-2 | story-seattle-time-st15 | seattle-times:ST15 | seattle-times:ST15 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-08-27 | paragraph 25 | N | own | hedged_check | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | Slanted, helped No | no |
Accurate and gives the three bases; does not state plainly that no exam is required.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-st15-3 | story-seattle-time-st15 | seattle-times:ST15 | seattle-times:ST15 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-08-27 | paragraph 7 | N | quote | unchecked | YBIRTH | checkbox | Can a doctor’s checkbox confirm a girl’s sex? | Right | yes |
Sec. 3(2) requires the provider to rely "only on" reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup or endogenous testosterone; birth records and medical history are not listed (LGW itself later said birth certificates cannot be used, ST Oct 28).
|
wa-i638-yes-campaign-claims | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts13-1 | story-the-stranger-ts13 | the-stranger:TS13 | the-stranger:TS13 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-08-28 | paragraph 19 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts13-2 | story-the-stranger-ts13 | the-stranger:TS13 | the-stranger:TS13 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-08-28 | paragraph 28 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
No-side label in own voice. p_lab trigger also 'conservative initiative organization' (para 23).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts14-1 | story-the-stranger-ts14 | the-stranger:TS14 | the-stranger:TS14 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-09-14 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_fund trigger; No-side donors (e.g., Inatai, SEIU 775, ACLU-WA) not named.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts14-2 | story-the-stranger-ts14 | the-stranger:TS14 | the-stranger:TS14 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-09-14 | paragraph 2 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts14-3 | story-the-stranger-ts14 | the-stranger:TS14 | the-stranger:TS14 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-09-14 | its headline | Y | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
'Anti-trans' is the No side's label; also p_lab trigger ('Republican', 'Conservative').
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-st16-1 | story-seattle-time-st16 | seattle-times:ST16 | seattle-times:ST16 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-09-24 | paragraph 1 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_lab: LGW and Kruse labeled conservative; complainant not characterized politically.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260927a-1 | story-spokesman-re-sr260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-09-27 | paragraph 11 | N | own | accurate | N510 | other | Other questions | Right | neutral |
WIAA estimate (no more than about 10); disclosure not required.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260927a-2 | story-spokesman-re-sr260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-09-27 | paragraph 14 | N | quote | unchecked | YDOC | checkbox | Can a doctor’s checkbox confirm a girl’s sex? | Right | yes |
Sec. 3(2) requires a provider-signed form verifying sex relying only on anatomy, genetics or testosterone; whether today's form records sex is not addressed in the story.
|
wa-i638-yes-campaign-claims | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260927a-3 | story-spokesman-re-sr260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-09-27 | paragraph 33 | N | own | false | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | neutral |
The Idaho law turns on biological sex/gender identity, not sexual orientation.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-sr260927a-4 | story-spokesman-re-sr260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | spokesman-review:SR260927a | Spokesman-Review | Spokesman-Review | 2026-09-27 | paragraph 4 | N | paraphrase | omission | NGEN | exam | Does I-638 require genital exams? | — | no |
Sec. 3(2) lets the provider rely on any one of anatomy, genetics or testosterone; no exam is named. Para 3 of the story prints the three bases.
|
wa-i638-genital-exam-claim | not corrected | coder | N | N |
| q-ts16-1 | story-the-stranger-ts16 | the-stranger:TS16 | the-stranger:TS16 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-09-28 | paragraph 2 | N | own | accurate | SCOPE | scope | Does I-638 ban trans girls from school sports? | Right | neutral |
Sec. 3(1) bars biologically male students only from female-only competition; boys' and open/coed teams are unaffected.
|
wa-i638-bans-trans-girls-from-sports | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts16-2 | story-the-stranger-ts16 | the-stranger:TS16 | the-stranger:TS16 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-09-28 | paragraph 3 | N | own | framing | OTHER | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
No-side label in own voice.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-ts16-3 | story-the-stranger-ts16 | the-stranger:TS16 | the-stranger:TS16 | The Stranger | The Stranger | 2026-09-28 | paragraph 3 | N | paraphrase | misleading | N510 | other | Other questions | Slanted, helped No | no |
WIAA has said it knows of 'no more than approximately 10' trans athletes and disclosure is not required; '5 to 10' is the No campaign's range. Name is also wrong (Activities, not Athletic).
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | Y |
| q-st18-1 | story-seattle-time-st18 | seattle-times:ST18 | seattle-times:ST18 | Seattle Times | Seattle Times | 2026-09-29 | paragraph 15 | N | own | omission | OTHER | other | Other questions | — | no |
p_fund trigger; No-side funding not mentioned.
|
— | not corrected | coder | N | N |
22 field definitions
| Field | Type | Meaning | Units | Value type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
statement_id |
string | ID of the statement in this dataset’s statements list. | — | observed |
source_id |
string | ID of the news story in sources. | — | observed |
story_uid |
string | Story copy ID: outlet folder and the coder’s story ID. | — | observed |
canonical_story_uid |
string | The copy each unique story is counted from (reprints are folded into one story). | — | derived |
newsroom |
string | Newsroom the statement is credited to: the one that wrote the story, except a headline on a reprint, which is credited to the paper that printed it. | — | derived |
printed_in |
string | Paper whose copy the statement was read in. | — | observed |
date |
date | Story publication date (YYYY-MM-DD). | — | observed |
location |
string | Where in the story: its headline, a paragraph number, or its text. | — | observed |
is_headline |
string | Y if the statement is the headline. | — | observed |
voice |
string | own (the paper’s own words), quote, or paraphrase. | — | derived |
item_type |
string | false, misleading, framing, hedged_check, flat_check, unchecked, omission (a quote that set off a paired test) or accurate. | — | derived |
claim_code |
string | Which recurring claim the statement concerns (codebook list), or OTHER. | — | derived |
question_key |
string | Claim-grid question the statement belongs to: exam, edge, scope, extreme, verify, checkbox or other. | — | derived |
question |
string | The claim-grid question in words. | — | derived |
placement |
string | Claim-grid column: Wrong or Slanted (helped Yes), Right, Slanted or Wrong (helped No). Empty when the statement is not placed (omission quotes, errors that help neither side). | — | derived |
side_helped |
string | yes, no or neutral: which side the statement helps if it is wrong or one-sided. | — | derived |
whats_true |
string | One sentence on what the measure’s text or a primary source shows. | — | derived |
rating_article |
string | Key of the FactHub article that rates the question’s claim (plain text, not a node reference). Empty for the other row. | — | derived |
correction |
string | corrected, not corrected or unknown, from correction notes on the page when read. | — | observed |
coding_source |
string | Who coded it: coder (outlet coder), rerun copy, rerun headline, merge coder, reconciled (from earlier verified work) or recoded at merge. | — | derived |
quote_is_correction_note |
string | Y when the quote is the paper’s correction notice rather than the original wording. | — | derived |
reference_outlet |
string | Y for The Stranger, a far-left weekly kept as a reference point and left out of the claim grid. | — | derived |