Audits
Did Black Friday get its name from stores going "into the black"?
Version 1. FactHub's auditors are automated reviewers, separate from the process that writes articles. Each checks a fixed, published list of things and grades the results with its own published rule. They can be wrong; an audit is not a human expert review. What this means · All auditors
Across versions
| Version | First Look |
|---|---|
| Version 1 | 7/7 |
First Look
A: Passes the first look: nothing obviously wrong. Minor notes may be reported as feedback without lowering the grade.
- Title matches the evidence
- No obvious contradictions
- Plausible justification
- Sources are relevant
- Common questions answered
- Headline and verdict agree
- No Wikipedia or open wikis
7 checks
-
Pass Title matches the evidence
The title asks whether the name came from stores going 'into the black', and the finding is False. The evidence items show police traffic use by 1961 and the profit explanation first appearing in 1981, so the title and rating point the same way as the evidence.
-
Pass No obvious contradictions
The established key points (police use by 1961, merchants pushing 'Big Friday', profit explanation first printed in 1981) match the conclusion and the evidence summaries. The 1970 ledger-ink joke is described in ev-profit and in the conclusion as a joke, not a profit claim, so it does not conflict with the 1981 date. Caveats such as 'earlier uses may exist' are nuance, not contradictions.
-
Pass Plausible justification
The conclusion says the rating rests on the order of dated uses: police and traffic use in 1961, the profit explanation in 1981, and merchants resisting the name. A reader would accept that this order shows the profit story came later, so the False rating follows from the stated reasons.
-
Pass Sources are relevant
Each source is on topic for what it supports: Library of Congress 1869 newspaper and House gold-panic report for the 1869 uses, Popik and Zimmer for the 1961 newsletter, Language Log for the 1975 and later uses, Merriam-Webster for the origin note, ShopperTrak, Adobe and PYMNTS for store and online spending, and FactHub records for the dated-use tables.
-
Pass Common questions answered
There are eight common questions. Each response addresses its question directly: the 1869 and 1745 predecessors, the store-versus-online biggest-day question, the online spending comparison, merchant reaction to the name, the dictionary's uncertainty, the slavery story, the 1951 factory use, and the Rochester and spread question.
-
Pass Headline and verdict agree
Step b sentence: 'Did Black Friday get its name from stores going "into the black"? No.' A reader takes away that the name did not come from store profits. The claim is positive, the title is positive, and the finding is False with short answer 'No', so the sentence agrees with the claim and the finding.
-
Pass No Wikipedia or open wikis
No cited source is Wikipedia or another open wiki. Sources are the Library of Congress, the U.S. House report, Barry Popik, Vocabulary.com, Language Log, Merriam-Webster, Sensormatic (ShopperTrak), ShopperTrak, Adobe, PYMNTS and FactHub records. The image credited to Wikimedia Commons is not a cited source and passes under the rule.
Coverage: I read the title, description, claim, finding, answer, conclusion, context, method, editorial note, all six evidence items with their limitations, all eight objections and responses, the key points, the source list with reliability notes, and every takeaway statement and quote. I did not open source snapshots, the web, or the linked archives, and I have no tools. Every takeaway in the sources is marked 'not yet checked', and none is marked established, so I treated all quotes and takeaway statements as unchecked. My judgments rest on internal consistency, not on whether the quotes match their sources. Of the key points, only the three marked 'established' were used as established; the others were treated as context. Noted but not reported: the article's objection 4 and the conclusion say researchers date the spread of the name to the 1970s and 1980s, while the Language Log takeaway (tk-spread) says Liberman dates the spread outside Philadelphia to 1987. The limitation in ev-profit acknowledges Liberman's dates, so I read this as a judgment call rather than an obvious contradiction. The conclusion's phrase 'from people who dreaded the day' is interpretive and was not treated as a finding. The image credit to Wikimedia Commons is not a cited source and was not counted under check 7.