What this dataset measures
Built to test the claim that Abraham Lincoln created Thanksgiving: it shows how often national thanksgivings were proclaimed before and after Lincoln's 1863 proclamation, which date each one used, and how states responded when the date was moved in 1939.
- Geography
- United States
- Unit of observation
- One national thanksgiving proclamation (table 1); one state in 1939 (table 2)
- Update cadence
- One-time compilation
- Curator
- FactHub Research Team
Supporting files
Source snapshots, manifests, quality reports, documentation,
and other materials used to produce or review this release.
-
build.py
Transformation manifest · text/x-python · 9.7 KB (9,903 bytes)
Script that builds the tables and analyses from the research notes.
-
computed.json
Documentation · application/json · 16.1 KB (16,534 bytes)
Saved-analysis results as JSON, produced by build.py.
Saved analyses
Years with a national thanksgiving, by period
Question: How many years in each period had a national thanksgiving?
Result: 1777-84: 8 of 8 years; 1785-88: 0 of 4; 1789-1862: 4 of 74; 1863-1945: 83 of 83.
Operation: Count distinct years with any thanksgiving proclamation by Congress (1777-1788) or a president (1789-1862), and with a yearly autumn proclamation (1863-1945).
Scope: Proclamations table
View this analysis
- 1789-1862 counts every presidential thanksgiving call, including Lincoln's April 1862 church thanksgiving with no fixed day.
Sources
-
The American Presidency Project, UC Santa Barbara: presidential proclamations
Full text of each presidential thanksgiving proclamation, 1789-1945, used for the signing date and the day named.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Transcriptions of public-domain documents. Underlying documents are public domain; we store only short phrases and dates
Reliability:
Academic.
An academic archive run by Gerhard Peters and John T. Woolley at UC Santa Barbara. It transcribes proclamations from the Statutes at Large and Messages and Papers of the Presidents. It has no stake in the date of Thanksgiving.
-
Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774-1789 (Library of Congress edition, 1904-37), scans on the Internet Archive
Congress's thanksgiving resolutions for 1777-1784 (volumes 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 23, 25 and 27; each row links its volume).
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability:
Government.
The official journal of the Continental and Confederation Congress, edited and printed by the Library of Congress. We read machine-read text of the scans, which has some character errors.
-
G. Wallace Chessman, "Thanksgiving: Another FDR Experiment," Prologue, Fall 1990 (National Archives)
Footnote 38 lists the date each of the 48 states observed in 1939, with its governor's party, from the New York Times of Oct. 17 and Nov. 23, 1939.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability:
Government.
Published in the National Archives' magazine, which says its articles don't necessarily represent the agency's views. The state list is the author's transcription of two New York Times tallies.
-
National Archives, Center for Legislative Archives: Congress Establishes Thanksgiving
Gives a different count for the 1939 split (32 states with the President, 16 against); recorded as a conflicting source.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability:
Government.
A short National Archives feature on the 1941 joint resolution. It does not list states or say which year its count describes.
-
U.S. Statutes at Large, vol. 55, p. 862: Joint resolution making the fourth Thursday in November a legal holiday (Dec. 26, 1941)
The law that fixed Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November from 1942 on.
Retrieved November 16, 2026. Public domain (U.S. government work). Free to redistribute
Reliability:
Government.
The official compilation of federal laws, scanned by the Library of Congress.
License: FactHub's selection, cleaning and combined tables are
licensed under CC BY 4.0.
Source data keeps the terms listed above (terms).
Limitations and reproducibility
Reproducible from linked public documents: Each proclamation row links its primary text and quotes the phrase naming the date. Weekdays and which Thursday of the month were computed from the Gregorian calendar. State rows are copied from the Prologue footnote.
- Counts only days named as thanksgiving days. Fast, humiliation, prayer and mourning days are left out, including Madison's 1813 day, which mixed thanks with humiliation.
- Four presidential calls had no single fixed day or covered only part of a day: Lincoln's April 1862 and September 1864 church thanksgivings, Harrison's one-hour centennial service in 1889, and McKinley's 1898 victory address. They are counted as one-time thanksgivings.
- State and colonial thanksgivings, held yearly in many states before 1863, are not in the proclamation table.
- The 1939 state list is a 1990 transcription of two New York Times tallies, not the governors' proclamations themselves. A separate National Archives page gives a different count (32 states for the new date, 16 against) without naming states or a year.
- Continental Congress quotes come from machine-read text of scanned volumes and keep its character errors.
Publications using this dataset
Version details
The exact citing versions, and the version of this dataset each cites.
-
Article
lincoln-thanksgiving-national-holiday —
version 1
(published) cites version 2
-
Chart
national-thanksgivings-by-year —
version 1
(published) cites version 2
-
Chart
thanksgiving-1939-state-split —
version 1
(published) cites version 2
-
Briefing
thanksgiving-facts —
version 3
(published) cites version 2
-
Briefing
thanksgiving-facts —
version 2
(published) cites version 2
Node: dataset:national-thanksgiving-proclamations:2:analysis:period-summary